Department of Hygiene and Public Health, Teikyo University School of Medicine, Tokyo.
Tohoku Institute for Management of Blood Pressure, Sendai, Japan.
J Hypertens. 2022 Feb 1;40(2):398-407. doi: 10.1097/HJH.0000000000003026.
The aim was to compare short-term and long-term reproducibilities of in-office unattended blood pressure (BP), namely automated office blood pressure (AOBP), conventionally measured attended office BP, and self-measured home BP.
A multicentre, clinical study was conducted in Japan, and 287 Japanese outpatients on antihypertensive drug medication were followed-up for 1 year.
The intensity of drug treatment was sustained consistently throughout the study period (defined daily doses, 1.62-1.68; P = 0.12). The mean SBP differences between baseline and 1 month later, as well as baseline and 1 year later, were less than 1.5 mmHg, whereas the standard deviations of the differences for home, AOBP, and attended office measurements for the 1-year interval were 7.7, 14.5, and 15.3 mmHg, respectively. The coefficients of variation were significantly smaller for home BP than for AOBP among all patients at both 1-month and 1-year intervals (P < 0.0001). In the 1-month interval, partial correlation coefficients of home BP (r, 0.73/0.88 for systolic/diastolic measures) were significantly higher than of conventional BP (r, 0.47/0.69). However, the correlations converged to the modest level regardless of BP information (r, 0.49-0.54/0.63-0.73) when the 1-year interval was assessed. Results were confirmatory when patients on the same drug regimen (n = 167) were analysed.
A higher reproducibility of home BP was demonstrated compared with in-office BP, including AOBP. However, the modest correlations for the 1-year interval support the importance of regular assessment of BP, regardless of in-office or home measurements for treatment of hypertension.
比较诊室非监测血压(即自动诊室血压(AOBP))、常规有医护人员监测诊室血压和家庭自测血压的短期和长期可重复性。
本研究为多中心临床研究,在日本进行,共随访 287 名正在接受降压药物治疗的日本门诊患者 1 年。
整个研究期间药物治疗强度保持一致(定义日剂量,1.62-1.68;P=0.12)。与基线相比,1 个月后和 1 年后的平均收缩压差值均小于 1.5mmHg,而家庭、AOBP 和有医护人员监测诊室测量的 1 年差值的标准差分别为 7.7、14.5 和 15.3mmHg。所有患者在 1 个月和 1 年间隔时,家庭血压的变异系数均显著小于 AOBP(P<0.0001)。在 1 个月间隔时,家庭血压的偏相关系数(r,收缩压/舒张压的 0.73/0.88)显著高于常规血压(r,0.47/0.69)。然而,当评估 1 年间隔时,无论血压信息如何,相关性均收敛至适度水平(r,0.49-0.54/0.63-0.73)。当分析使用相同药物治疗方案的患者(n=167)时,结果是可确认的。
与诊室血压(包括 AOBP)相比,家庭血压的可重复性更高。然而,1 年间隔时的适度相关性支持定期评估血压的重要性,无论治疗高血压时使用诊室或家庭测量值。