Muñiz Ruben, López-Álvarez Jorge, Perea Luis, Rivera Sofía, González Liliana, Olazarán Javier
Maria Wolff Foundation, Madrid, Spain.
Psychiatry Department, University Hospital 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain.
J Alzheimers Dis Rep. 2021 Aug 6;5(1):613-624. doi: 10.3233/ADR-210015. eCollection 2021.
Over- and potentially inappropriate prescribing of psychotropic medications is a major public health concern among people with dementia.
Describe the emical estraints avidance thodology (CHROME) criteria and evaluate its effects on psychotropic prescribing and quality of life (QoL).
Observational, prospective, two-wave study conducted in two nursing homes. A multicomponent program to eliminate chemical restraints and attain quality prescription of psychotropic medications was implemented. CHROME's diagnostic criteria comprise constellations of behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia under six primary syndromic diagnoses. Since pharmacologic treatment is aimed at only one syndrome, polypharmacy is avoided. Psychotropic prescription, QoL, neuropsychiatric symptoms (NPS), and other clinical measurements were collected before and one year after the intervention. Results are presented for all residents ( = 171) and for completer subjects ( = 115).
Mean age (SD) of the residents was 87.8 (5.7), 78.9% were women, and 68.5% suffered advanced dementia. Psychotropic prescriptions decreased from 1.9 (1.1) to 0.9 (1.0) ( < 0.0005). Substantive reduction in prescribing frequency was observed for antidepressants (76.9% pre-intervention, 33.8% post-intervention) and for atypical neuroleptics (38.8% pre-intervention, 15.1% post-intervention). There was improvement in patient's response to surroundings ( < 0.0005) and total NPS ( < 0.01), but small worsening occurred in social interaction ( < 0.02, completer subjects). Safety measurements remained stable.
CHROME criteria appear to optimize psychotropic prescriptions, avoid chemical restraints, and allow external verification of quality prescriptions. Extensive use seems feasible, related to substantial reduction of prescriptions, and of benefit for people with dementia as de-prescriptions are not associated to increased NPS or QoL loss.
精神药物的过度及潜在不适当处方是痴呆症患者的一个主要公共卫生问题。
描述化学约束规避方法(CHROME)标准,并评估其对精神药物处方及生活质量(QoL)的影响。
在两家养老院进行观察性、前瞻性、两阶段研究。实施了一项消除化学约束并实现精神药物优质处方的多组分项目。CHROME的诊断标准包括六种主要综合征诊断下的痴呆行为和心理症状群。由于药物治疗仅针对一种综合征,避免了多药联用。在干预前和干预一年后收集精神药物处方、生活质量、神经精神症状(NPS)及其他临床测量数据。呈现了所有居民(n = 171)和完成研究对象(n = 115)的结果。
居民的平均年龄(标准差)为87.8(5.7)岁,78.9%为女性,68.5%患有晚期痴呆症。精神药物处方从1.9(1.1)降至0.9(1.0)(P < 0.0005)。观察到抗抑郁药(干预前76.9%,干预后33.8%)和非典型抗精神病药(干预前38.8%,干预后15.1%)的处方频率大幅降低。患者对周围环境的反应(P < 0.0005)和总NPS(P < 0.01)有所改善,但社交互动出现小幅恶化(P < 0.02,完成研究对象)。安全测量保持稳定。
CHROME标准似乎能优化精神药物处方,避免化学约束,并允许对优质处方进行外部验证。广泛应用似乎可行,与处方大幅减少相关,且对痴呆症患者有益,因为减少用药与NPS增加或生活质量下降无关。