Department of Biomedical Metabolic and Neuro Sciences, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy.
Department of Surgery Medicine Dentistry and Morphological Sciences with an Interest in Transplant Oncology, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy.
J Occup Environ Hyg. 2021 Dec;18(12):541-546. doi: 10.1080/15459624.2021.1989442. Epub 2021 Oct 20.
This study was aimed to assess the efficacy of dry steam in inactivating Human Coronavirus OC43 (HCoV-OC43) as surrogate of SARS-CoV-2, Human Influenza Virus A/H1N1/WSN/33 and Echovirus 7 on stainless steel, polypropylene, and cotton. The virus models were chosen on the basis of their transmission route and environmental resistance. Tests were carried out under a laminar flow cabinet, where two panels of each material were contaminated with a viral suspension. The inocula were left to dry and then the virus on untreated panel (control) was collected by swabbing in order to determine the initial titer. The other panel was treated using a professional vacuum cleaner equipped with a dry steam generator. Dry steam is generated in a boiler where tap water is heated up to 155 °C at 5.5 bar pressure and then during the passage along the flexible hose the temperature decreases to a value between 100 °C and 110 °C at the output. The dry steam was applied for four sec with a window wiper on metal and plastic panels or a brush covered by a microfiber cap on cotton, simulating the steam application during routine cleaning. After the treatment, infectious virus possibly remained on the surface was collected following the same swabbing procedure applied for controls. HCoV-OC43 and Echovirus 7 were titrated by end-point method on HCT-8 line cells and Vero cells, respectively, while Human Influenza Virus was quantified by plaque reduction assay on MDCK cells. Dry steam resulted effective against the three viruses on all tested materials, achieving a mean Log reduction factor ≥4 in viral titer of treated samples compared with controls according to UNI EN 14476:2019. Thus, dry steam may be proposed as an ease to use, effective, fast, and nontoxic alternative to chemicals for surface disinfection without damaging materials. Therefore, this device could be employed not only in healthcare facilities but also in occupational, domestic, and community settings, with advantages for environment and human health.
本研究旨在评估干蒸汽对不锈钢、聚丙烯和棉织物表面上的人冠状病毒 OC43(HCoV-OC43)、人流感病毒 A/H1N1/WSN/33 和肠病毒 7 的灭活效果,这些病毒模型是基于其传播途径和环境抗性选择的。试验在层流柜中进行,将每种材料的两块面板用病毒悬液进行污染。接种物干燥后,通过擦拭未处理面板(对照)收集未经处理的病毒,以确定初始滴度。另一块面板使用配备干蒸汽发生器的专业吸尘器进行处理。干蒸汽在锅炉中产生,其中自来水在 5.5 巴的压力下加热至 155°C,然后在通过柔性软管的过程中,温度在输出时降至 100°C 至 110°C 之间。干蒸汽在金属和塑料面板上用窗刮器或用微纤维帽覆盖的刷子在棉织物上施加 4 秒,模拟日常清洁过程中的蒸汽施加。处理后,采用与对照相同的擦拭程序收集表面上可能残留的传染性病毒。通过终点法在 HCT-8 细胞上滴定 HCoV-OC43 和肠病毒 7,在 MDCK 细胞上通过蚀斑减少试验定量测定人流感病毒。干蒸汽对所有测试材料上的三种病毒均有效,与对照相比,处理样品中的病毒滴度平均 Log 减少因子≥4,符合 UNI EN 14476:2019 标准。因此,干蒸汽可作为一种易于使用、有效、快速且无毒的替代化学物质,用于表面消毒,而不会损坏材料。因此,该设备不仅可在医疗保健设施中使用,还可在职业、家庭和社区环境中使用,对环境和人类健康具有优势。