Université McGill, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Université McGill, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Int Dent J. 2022 Aug;72(4):529-535. doi: 10.1016/j.identj.2021.08.057. Epub 2021 Oct 14.
Dental leadership in different models of care is not well documented, and therefore the objectives of this study were to explore how dental leaders develop their own leadership and how they engage others to increase access to oral health services as well as to describe perceived challenges in developing coalitions for promoting oral health care.
We adopted a qualitative descriptive research methodology. We recruited dental leaders using a purposeful sampling approach and a snowball technique. Data were collected using a remote digital platform; we organised semi-structured interviews based on the LEADS conceptual framework. Saturation was reached after 11 interviews. Data analysis included the following iterative steps: decontextualisation, recontextualisation, categorisation, and data compilation. The analysis was performed manually, assisted by the use of QDA Miner software.
Fourteen dental leaders participated in the study. Our analysis revealed 3 overarching themes: (I) lead self, with 3 subthemes: leadership insights; leadership traits; opportunity-role model dyad; (II) leadership strategies; and (III) challenges in leadership development, with 3 subthemes: limited engaged practice and workforce, valorise the image of dentistry, and lack of leadership training.
Our research findings showed that, despite a limited scope of leadership in dentistry, the dental leaders recognise its importance and acknowledge the need for formal training and mentorship at different levels. This study identified challenges in dental leadership development that could further orient dental education programmes and support the implementation of evidence-based, high-quality, and efficient oral health services.
不同模式的口腔护理中,牙科领导力的相关记录并不完善,因此本研究旨在探索牙科领导者如何发展自身领导力,以及如何吸引他人来增加获得口腔健康服务的机会,并描述在为促进口腔保健而组建联盟时遇到的挑战。
我们采用定性描述性研究方法。我们通过有目的的抽样方法和滚雪球技术招募了牙科领导者。使用远程数字平台收集数据;我们根据 LEADS 概念框架组织了半结构化访谈。在进行了 11 次访谈后,达到了饱和度。数据分析包括以下迭代步骤:去语境化、重新语境化、分类和数据汇编。分析是手动进行的,同时借助 QDA Miner 软件辅助。
14 名牙科领导者参与了这项研究。我们的分析揭示了 3 个总体主题:(I)自我领导,包括 3 个子主题:领导力洞察力;领导力特质;机会-榜样的双重作用;(II)领导策略;以及(III)领导力发展中的挑战,包括 3 个子主题:有限的实践和劳动力参与、提升牙科形象以及缺乏领导力培训。
我们的研究结果表明,尽管牙科领域的领导力范围有限,但牙科领导者认识到其重要性,并认识到需要在不同层面进行正式的培训和指导。本研究确定了牙科领导力发展中存在的挑战,这可以进一步指导牙科教育计划,并支持实施基于证据、高质量和高效的口腔健康服务。