Social and Preventive Medicine, Laval University, Québec, Canada.
Biology, Laval University, Québec, Canada.
Environ Monit Assess. 2021 Oct 21;193(11):740. doi: 10.1007/s10661-021-09485-1.
Honeybees have been used in Europe as environmental bioindicators for heavy metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). However, their potential has been little explored in North America, especially between environments which have similar pollution levels. Many urban residents and stakeholders are concerned with air quality, mainly in regard to gradients of exposure to industrial pollution between deprived and privileged subpopulation. Thus, the aim of this study was to evaluate the use of honeybees as bioindicators to assess exposure to heavy metals and PAHs in Québec City, Canada, in different socioeconomic districts of Quebec City (deprivation index). Honeybees were sampled over a 5-month period (May to September) at six locations distributed in two urban areas that are distinct geomorphologically and socioeconomically (lower town socio-economically deprived and upper town socioeconomically privileged) and two control rural locations. Six PAHs were analyzed by ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC), while four heavy metals were analyzed by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Arsenic was the only measured pollutant that showed a significant gradient of exposure between rural and urban environments, but also between the two urban areas. Furthermore, we were able to detect significant differences at certain sampling times for heavy metals and PAHs. Overall, the results show that honeybees are sensitive enough to detect differences between the differential urban environments of a city presumed to have similar pollution levels and therefore could be used when potential socio-environmental inequalities are present.
在欧洲,蜜蜂被用作重金属和多环芳烃 (PAHs) 的环境生物标志物。然而,它们在北美的潜力尚未得到充分探索,尤其是在污染水平相似的环境之间。许多城市居民和利益相关者关心空气质量,主要是关注工业污染在贫困和特权亚人群之间的暴露梯度。因此,本研究的目的是评估蜜蜂作为生物标志物在评估加拿大魁北克市不同社会经济地区(剥夺指数)暴露于重金属和 PAHs 中的应用。在五个月的时间里(5 月至 9 月),在分布在两个具有明显地貌和社会经济差异的城市地区(下城区社会经济贫困,上城区社会经济富裕)和两个控制农村地区的六个地点采集了蜜蜂样本。采用超高效液相色谱法 (UPLC) 分析了 6 种 PAHs,采用电感耦合等离子体质谱法 (ICP-MS) 分析了 4 种重金属。砷是唯一一种显示出农村和城市环境之间以及两个城市地区之间暴露梯度差异的污染物,但也显示出差异。此外,我们还能够在某些采样时间检测到重金属和 PAHs 的显著差异。总的来说,结果表明蜜蜂对城市环境之间的差异非常敏感,即使城市之间的污染水平相似,也能检测到差异,因此当存在潜在的社会环境不平等时,可以使用蜜蜂来进行检测。