Whiteside Bianca, Dunn Matthew
School of Health and Social Development, Faculty of Health, Deakin University, Geelong, Australia.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2022 May;41(4):818-829. doi: 10.1111/dar.13392. Epub 2021 Oct 21.
The media's influence on policy has been widely documented. This study sought to investigate how Melbourne's medically supervised injecting room (MSIR) was represented in the print media.
A qualitative discourse analysis of Victorian print media (n = 441 items) representation of MSIR was conducted. Constructivist Grounded Theory guided the sampling strategy and coding while the discourse analysis was informed by Bacchi's approach to policy analysis, 'What's the problem represented to be?'. Print news media was gathered from Factiva and Newsbank databases from January 2016 to June 2020.
The media's representation of the 'drug problem' of overdose was identified by a range of actors in support and opposition of the facility. In attributing the concept of 'drug use' to the 'drug problem' items most frequently suggest it is the 'choice' of the individual to inject illicit drugs. The voices of people who inject drugs (PWID) were largely silenced in the print news media and to re-conceptualise the 'drug problem' to be a 'health problem' would aid in the support for the harm reduction strategy. The research highlighted 'dividing practices' (residents vs. PWID) and the portrayal of PWID that translate to the lived effects of PWID.
The print news media did not directly influence the establishment of the Melbourne MSIR. However, the representation of PWID in the print media must be further investigated for the successful establishment of future harm reduction strategies.
媒体对政策的影响已有大量记载。本研究旨在调查墨尔本的医疗监督注射室(MSIR)在平面媒体中的呈现方式。
对维多利亚州平面媒体(n = 441篇文章)中MSIR的呈现进行了定性话语分析。建构主义扎根理论指导抽样策略和编码,而话语分析则借鉴了巴奇的政策分析方法“所呈现的问题是什么?”。平面新闻媒体是从2016年1月至2020年6月的Factiva和Newsbank数据库中收集的。
支持和反对该设施的一系列行为者确定了媒体对过量用药“毒品问题”的呈现。在将“吸毒”概念归因于“毒品问题”时,文章最常认为注射非法药物是个人的“选择”。在平面新闻媒体中,注射吸毒者(PWID)的声音基本被压制,将“毒品问题”重新概念化为“健康问题”将有助于支持减少伤害战略。该研究突出了“区分做法”(居民与PWID)以及对PWID的描绘,这些都转化为PWID的实际生活影响。
平面新闻媒体并未直接影响墨尔本MSIR的设立。然而,为了成功制定未来的减少伤害战略,必须进一步调查平面媒体中对PWID的呈现。