Baumrind S, Korn E L, Ben-Bassat Y, West E E
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1987 Jan;91(1):29-41. doi: 10.1016/0889-5406(87)90206-x.
Lateral skull radiographs for a set of 31 human subjects were examined using computer-aided methods in an attempt to quantify modal trends of maxillary remodeling during the mixed dentition and adolescent growth periods. Cumulative changes in position of anterior nasal spine (ANS), posterior nasal spine (PNS), and Point A are reported at annual intervals relative to superimposition on previously placed maxillary metallic implants. This in vivo longitudinal study confirms at a high level of confidence earlier findings by Enlow, Björk, Melsen, and others to the effect that the superior surface of the maxilla remodels downward during the period of growth and development being investigated. However, the inter-individual variability is relatively large, the mean magnitudes of change are relatively small, and the rate of change appears to diminish by 13.5 years. For the 19 subjects for whom data were available for the time interval from 8.5 to 15.5 years, mean downward remodeling at PNS was 2.50 mm with a standard deviation of 2.23 mm. At ANS, corresponding mean value was 1.56 mm with a standard deviation of 2.92 mm. Mean rotation of the ANS-PNS line relative to the implant line was 1.1 degree in the "forward" direction. However, this rotational change was particularly variable with a standard deviation of 4.6 degrees and a range of 11.3 degrees "forward" to 6.7 degrees "backward." The study provides strong evidence that the palate elongates anteroposteriorly mainly by the backward remodeling of structures located posterior to the region in which the implants were placed. There is also evidence that supports the idea of modal resorptive remodeling at ANS and PNS, but here the data are somewhat more equivocal. It appears likely, but not certain, that there are real differences in the modal patterns of remodeling between treated and untreated subjects. Because of problems associated with overfragmentation of the sample, sex differences were not investigated.
对31名人类受试者的颅骨侧位X线片采用计算机辅助方法进行检查,试图量化混合牙列期和青少年生长期上颌骨重塑的模式趋势。报告了相对于先前放置的上颌金属植入物的叠加情况,每年前鼻棘(ANS)、后鼻棘(PNS)和A点位置的累积变化。这项体内纵向研究在很高的置信水平上证实了恩洛、比约克、梅尔森等人早期的研究结果,即在正在研究的生长发育期间,上颌骨上表面向下重塑。然而,个体间的变异性相对较大,变化的平均幅度相对较小,且变化率在13.5岁时似乎有所下降。对于19名在8.5至15.5岁时间间隔内有数据的受试者,PNS处的平均向下重塑为2.50毫米,标准差为2.23毫米。在ANS处,相应的平均值为1.56毫米,标准差为2.92毫米。ANS - PNS线相对于植入物线的平均旋转角度为“向前”1.1度。然而,这种旋转变化特别具有变异性,标准差为4.6度,范围为“向前”11.3度至“向后”6.7度。该研究提供了有力证据,表明腭主要通过植入物放置区域后方结构的向后重塑而前后伸长。也有证据支持ANS和PNS处存在模式性吸收重塑的观点,但此处的数据有些模棱两可。在治疗组和未治疗组受试者之间的重塑模式可能存在真正差异,但不确定。由于样本过度碎片化相关的问题,未对性别差异进行研究。