Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University Medical Center of Tübingen, 72076 Tübingen, Germany.
Eberhard Karls University Tübingen, 72076 Tübingen, Germany.
Medicina (Kaunas). 2021 Oct 4;57(10):1062. doi: 10.3390/medicina57101062.
: Preoperative planning utilizing computed tomographies (CT) is of utmost importance in functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). Frequently, no uniform documentation and planning structures are available to residents in training. Consequently, overall completeness and quality of operation planning may vary greatly. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the impact of a structured operation planning (SOP) approach on the report quality and user convenience during a 4-day sinus surgery course. : Fifteen participant were requested to plan a FESS procedure based on a CT scan of the paranasal sinuses that exhibited common pathological features, in a conventional manner, using a free text. Afterwards, the participants reevaluated the same scans by means of a specifically designed structured reporting template. Two experienced ENT surgeons assessed the collected conventional operation planning (COP) and SOP methods independently with regard to time requirements, overall quality, and legibility. User convenience data were collected by utilizing visual analogue scales. : A significantly greater time expenditure was associated with SOPs (183 s vs. 297 s, = 0.0003). Yet, legibility (100% vs. 72%, < 0.0001) and overall completeness (61.3% vs. 22.7%, < 0.0001) of SOPs was significantly superior to COPs. Additionally, description of highly relevant variants in anatomy and pathologies were outlined in greater detail. User convenience data delineated a significant preference for SOPs (VAS 7.9 vs. 6.9, = 0.0185). : CT-based planning of FESS procedures by residents in training using a structured approach is more time-consuming while producing a superior report quality in terms of detailedness and readability. Consequently, SOP can be considered as a valuable tool in the process of preoperative evaluations, especially within residency.
: 术前规划利用计算机断层扫描(CT)在功能性内窥镜鼻窦手术(FESS)中至关重要。通常,住院医师培训中没有统一的文档和规划结构。因此,手术规划的整体完整性和质量可能会有很大差异。本研究的目的是评估结构化手术规划(SOP)方法对 4 天鼻窦手术课程中报告质量和用户便利性的影响。 : 15 名参与者被要求根据 CT 扫描规划 FESS 手术,该扫描显示常见的病理特征,以常规方式使用自由文本。然后,参与者通过专门设计的结构化报告模板重新评估相同的扫描。两位经验丰富的耳鼻喉科外科医生独立评估收集的常规手术规划(COP)和 SOP 方法,评估内容包括时间要求、整体质量和可读性。用户便利性数据通过使用视觉模拟量表收集。 : SOP 的时间消耗明显更高(183 秒对 297 秒, = 0.0003)。然而,SOP 的可读性(100%对 72%,<0.0001)和整体完整性(61.3%对 22.7%,<0.0001)明显优于 COP。此外,还更详细地描述了解剖结构和病理学中的高度相关变体。用户便利性数据表明,SOP 具有明显的优势(VAS 7.9 对 6.9,= 0.0185)。 : 使用结构化方法对 FESS 手术进行基于 CT 的规划,尽管时间消耗更长,但在详细程度和可读性方面可提供更好的报告质量。因此,SOP 可以被视为术前评估过程中的一种有价值的工具,特别是在住院医师培训中。