Salva Eumelia P, Villarama Jose Benito, Lopez Edmundo B, Sayo Ana Ria, Villanueva Annavi Marie G, Edwards Tansy, Han Su Myat, Suzuki Shuichi, Seposo Xerxes, Ariyoshi Koya, Smith Chris
San Lazaro Hospital, Manila, Philippines.
School of Tropical Medicine and Global Health, Nagasaki University, Nagasaki, Japan.
Trop Med Health. 2020 Jun 22;48(1):51. doi: 10.1186/s41182-020-00241-8.
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has spread to almost every region and country in the world, leading to widespread travel restrictions and national lockdowns. Currently, there are limited epidemiological and clinical data on COVID-19 patients from low and middle-income countries. We conducted a retrospective single-center study of the first 100 individuals with suspected COVID-19 (between Jan. 25 and Mar. 29, 2020) admitted to San Lazaro Hospital (SLH), the national infectious diseases referral hospital in Manila, Philippines.
Demographic data, travel history, clinical features, and outcomes were summarized and compared between COVID-19 confirmed and non-confirmed cases. The first two confirmed cases were Chinese nationals, admitted on Jan. 25. The third confirmed case was a Filipino, admitted on Mar. 8. Trends toward confirmed COVID-19 cases not reporting international travel and being admitted to SLH from the densely populated area of Manila city were observed during Mar. 8-29. All 42 of the 100 confirmed COVID-19 cases were adults, 40% were aged 60 years and above and 55% were male. Three were health workers. Among individuals with suspected COVID-19, confirmed cases were more likely to be older, Filipino, not report international travel history and have at least one underlying disease, particularly diabetes, report difficulty in breathing, and a longer duration of symptoms. In over 90% of non-COVID-19 cases, the alternative diagnosis was respiratory. Nine (21%) confirmed cases died. The median duration from symptoms onset to death was 11.5 (range: 8-18) days.
Imported COVID-19 cases have reduced but local transmission persists and there is a trend toward cases being admitted to SLH from densely populated areas. This study highlights the difficulty in diagnosing COVID-19 on clinical grounds and the importance of diagnostic capacity in all settings. Difficulty of breathing was the only symptom associated with COVID-19 infection and should alert clinicians to the possibility of COVID-19. Clinical characteristics of confirmed COVID-19 cases and a hospital case fatality rate of 21% are comparable with other settings.
2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)已蔓延至世界上几乎每个地区和国家,导致广泛的旅行限制和全国封锁。目前,来自低收入和中等收入国家的COVID-19患者的流行病学和临床数据有限。我们对菲律宾马尼拉的国家传染病转诊医院圣拉萨罗医院(SLH)收治的首批100例疑似COVID-19患者(2020年1月25日至3月29日)进行了一项回顾性单中心研究。
总结并比较了COVID-19确诊病例和非确诊病例的人口统计学数据、旅行史、临床特征及转归。前两例确诊病例为中国公民,于1月25日入院。第三例确诊病例为菲律宾人,于3月8日入院。在3月8日至29日期间,观察到确诊的COVID-19病例有未报告国际旅行史以及从马尼拉市人口密集地区被收治到SLH的趋势。100例确诊的COVID-19病例均为成年人,40%年龄在60岁及以上,55%为男性。其中3人为医护人员。在疑似COVID-19的个体中,确诊病例更可能年龄较大、为菲律宾人、未报告国际旅行史且至少有一种基础疾病,尤其是糖尿病,报告有呼吸困难且症状持续时间较长。在超过90%的非COVID-19病例中,替代诊断为呼吸道疾病。9例(21%)确诊病例死亡。从症状出现到死亡持续时间的中位数为11.5天(范围:8 - 18天)。
输入性COVID-19病例有所减少,但本地传播仍然存在,且有从人口密集地区收治到SLH的病例趋势。本研究强调了基于临床诊断COVID-19的困难以及在所有环境中诊断能力的重要性。呼吸困难是与COVID-19感染相关的唯一症状,应提醒临床医生注意COVID-19的可能性。确诊的COVID-19病例的临床特征以及21%的医院病死率与其他情况相当。