Qazi Atika, Hasan Najmul, Abayomi-Alli Olusola, Hardaker Glenn, Scherer Ronny, Sarker Yeahia, Kumar Paul Sanjoy, Maitama Jaafar Zubairu
Center for lifelong learning, Universiti Brunei Darussalam, Gadong, Brunei.
Center for Modern Information Management, School of Management, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430074 People's Republic of China.
Educ Inf Technol (Dordr). 2022;27(3):4225-4258. doi: 10.1007/s10639-021-10775-x. Epub 2021 Oct 21.
Even though information and communication technology (ICT) is essential for everyday life and has gained considerable attention in education and other sectors, it also carries individual differences in its use and relevant skills. This systematic review aims to examine the gender differences in ICT use and skills for learning through technology. A comprehensive search of eight journal databases and a specific selection criterion was carried out to exclude articles that match our stated exclusion criteria. We included 42 peer-reviewed empirical publications and conference proceedings published between 2006 and 2020. For a subsample of studies, we performed a small-scale meta-analysis to quantify possible gender differences in ICT use and skills. A random-effects model uncovered a small and positive, yet not significant, effect size in favor of boys ( = 0.17, 95% CI [-0.01, 0.36]). However, this finding needs to be further backed by large-scale meta-analyses, including more study samples and a broader set of ICT use and skills measures. We highlight several concerns that should be addressed and more thoroughly in collaboration with one another to better IT skills and inspire new policies to increase the quality of ICT use. The findings from this review further suggest implications and present existing research challenges and point to future research directions.
尽管信息通信技术(ICT)对日常生活至关重要,且在教育和其他领域已备受关注,但在其使用和相关技能方面仍存在个体差异。本系统综述旨在研究通过技术进行学习时,ICT使用和技能方面的性别差异。我们对八个期刊数据库进行了全面检索,并采用特定的选择标准来排除符合我们既定排除标准的文章。我们纳入了2006年至2020年间发表的42篇同行评审的实证研究论文和会议论文。对于部分研究子样本,我们进行了小规模的荟萃分析,以量化ICT使用和技能方面可能存在的性别差异。随机效应模型发现了一个虽小但为正向的效应量,不过不显著,有利于男孩(效应量 = 0.17,95%置信区间[-0.01, 0.36])。然而,这一发现需要通过大规模的荟萃分析进一步佐证,包括更多的研究样本以及更广泛的ICT使用和技能衡量指标。我们强调了几个需要相互协作更深入探讨的问题,以提升信息技术技能,并激发新政策来提高ICT使用质量。本综述的研究结果进一步表明了相关影响,呈现了现有研究的挑战,并指出了未来的研究方向。