Dinnella Caterina, Pierguidi Lapo, Spinelli Sara, Borgogno Monica, Gallina Toschi Tullia, Predieri Stefano, Lavezzi Giliana, Trapani Francesca, Tura Matilde, Magli Massimiliano, Bendini Alessandra, Monteleone Erminio
Department of Agriculture, Food, Environment and Forestry (DAGRI), University of Florence, Italy.
Mérieux NutriSciences, Italy.
Food Qual Prefer. 2022 Mar;96:104437. doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2021.104437. Epub 2021 Oct 15.
Restrictions adopted by many countries in 2020 due to Covid-19 pandemic had severe consequences on the management of sensory and consumer testing that strengthened the tendency to move data collection out of the laboratory. Remote sensory testing, organized at the assessor's home or workplace and carried out under the live online supervision of the panel leader, represents a trade-off between adequate control and the convenience of conducting testing out of the lab. The Italian Sensory Science Society developed the "Remote sensory testing" research project aimed at testing the effectiveness and validity of the sensory tests conducted remotely through a comparison with evaluations in a classical laboratory setting. Guidelines were developed to assist panel leaders in setting up and controlling the evaluation sessions in remote testing conditions. Different methods were considered: triangle and tetrad tests, Descriptive Analysis and Temporal Dominance of Sensations tests, all of which involved trained panels, and Check-All-That-Apply and hedonic tests with consumers. Remote sensory testing provided similar results to the lab testing in all the cases, with the exception of the tetrad test run at work. Findings suggest that remote sensory testing, if conducted in strict compliance with specifically developed sensory protocols, is a promising alternative to laboratory tests that can be applied with both trained assessors and consumers even beyond the global pandemic.
2020年,许多国家因新冠疫情采取的限制措施对感官测试和消费者测试的管理产生了严重影响,强化了将数据收集移出实验室的趋势。远程感官测试在评估员的家中或工作场所进行,并在小组组长的实时在线监督下开展,是在充分控制与在实验室外进行测试的便利性之间的一种权衡。意大利感官科学协会开展了“远程感官测试”研究项目,旨在通过与传统实验室环境下的评估进行比较,测试远程进行的感官测试的有效性和效度。制定了指南,以协助小组组长在远程测试条件下设置和控制评估环节。考虑了不同的方法:三角和四重检验、描述性分析和感官强度随时间变化测试(所有这些都涉及经过培训的小组),以及针对消费者的复选和享乐测试。除了在工作场所进行的四重检验外,远程感官测试在所有情况下都提供了与实验室测试相似的结果。研究结果表明,如果严格按照专门制定的感官规程进行,远程感官测试是实验室测试的一个有前景的替代方案,即使在全球疫情之后,也可应用于经过培训的评估员和消费者。