Andrews Sally E, Roberts Graham, Set Pat, Warburton Fiona, Gilbert Fiona J
Department of Radiology, Addenbrooke's Hospital, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Department of Orthodontics, King's College Dental Institute, London, UK.
J Forensic Sci. 2022 Jan;67(1):229-242. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.14928. Epub 2021 Nov 3.
Population differences in dental development between Black and White ethnic groups have been debated but not previously studied in the UK. Using inappropriate data for dental age estimation (DAE) could lead to erroneous results and injustice. Data were collected from dental panoramic radiographs of 5590 subjects aged 6-24 years in a teaching hospital archive. Demirjian stages were determined for left-sided teeth and third molars and data collected regarding hypodontia and third molar agenesis. Third molar development in self-assigned Black British, including other self-assigned Black ethnicity, was compared with that of self-assigned White British subjects. Data were compared for males and females in the two ethnic groups using T-tests for Demirjian Stages A-G of third molar development and Mann-Whitney tests for Stage H once a cut-off age at the maximum age for Stage G had been imposed. Third molar development occurred earlier in subjects of Black ancestry compared to those of White ancestry. While both ethnic groups showed large age ranges for every third molar stage, in female subjects these generally occurred at least 1.5 years earlier, and in males at least one year earlier. Hypodontia and third molar agenesis were more prevalent in White British, but the ethnic difference in third molar development persisted in subjects with complete dentitions. This is a large study that confirms ethnic differences in a London population, emphasises the difficulties of establishing the 18-year-old threshold using DAE, and confirms the risk of overestimating the age of individuals of Black ethnicity using White ethnic reference data.
黑人和白人种族群体在牙齿发育方面的人口差异一直存在争议,但此前在英国尚未进行过研究。使用不恰当的数据进行牙齿年龄估计(DAE)可能会导致错误的结果和不公正现象。从一家教学医院档案中收集了5590名6至24岁受试者的口腔全景X光片数据。确定左侧牙齿和第三磨牙的德米尔坚阶段,并收集有关牙齿发育不全和第三磨牙缺失的数据。将自我认定为英国黑人(包括其他自我认定的黑人种族)的第三磨牙发育情况与自我认定为英国白人的受试者进行比较。使用T检验比较两个种族群体中男性和女性第三磨牙发育德米尔坚阶段A - G的数据,对于阶段H,在设定阶段G的最大年龄截止点后,使用曼 - 惠特尼检验。与白人血统的受试者相比,黑人血统的受试者第三磨牙发育更早。虽然两个种族群体的每个第三磨牙阶段都显示出较大的年龄范围,但在女性受试者中,这些阶段通常至少提前1.5年出现,在男性中至少提前一年出现。牙齿发育不全和第三磨牙缺失在英国白人中更为普遍,但在牙列完整的受试者中,第三磨牙发育的种族差异仍然存在。这是一项大型研究,证实了伦敦人群中的种族差异,强调了使用DAE确定18岁阈值的困难,并证实了使用白人种族参考数据高估黑人种族个体年龄的风险。