Liu Ji-Yan, Li Xiang
Department of Academic Journals, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou, China.
Institute of Clinical Medicine, Zhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou, China.
Anat Rec (Hoboken). 2023 Dec;306(12):2974-2983. doi: 10.1002/ar.24821. Epub 2021 Nov 5.
The standardization, objectification, and essence research of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) syndrome influence the modernization and international development of TCM syndrome. A total of 253 relevant publications collected from the Web of Science Core Collection database from 2006 to 2020 were analyzed by bibliometric and content methods. The co-occurrence analysis of countries, institutions, journals, authors, and keywords analysis were carried out by using Citespace software. The high-yield institutions and high-impact authors contributed to TCM syndrome publications were concentrated in China. Since 2012, driven by some groundbreaking publications, the number of TCM syndrome literatures has increased rapidly. According to the results of bibliometric and content analysis, research hotspots in TCM syndrome in the last 15 years can be summarized in six aspects: (a) objectification research of four TCM diagnostic methods, (b) omics technology for the essence research of TCM syndrome, (c) research on TCM syndrome evaluation scale, (d) metagenomic technology for the essence research of TCM syndrome, (e) data mining technology for TCM syndrome differentiation, and (f) systematic research on TCM syndromes of chronic hepatitis B. Emerging trends can be identified according to the most recent keywords bursts: (a) TCM syndrome diagnostic models with multiple indexes should be constructed to develop personalized medicine. (b) The connotation of TCM syndrome should be verified through "syndrome detecting from recipe used," and the screened potential markers of TCM syndrome need clinical verification. (c) The intervention and integration of multi-disciplines is expected to find a new breakthrough in the research of TCM syndrome.
中医证候的标准化、客观化及本质研究影响着中医证候的现代化及国际化发展。运用文献计量学和内容分析法,对2006年至2020年从Web of Science核心合集数据库收集的253篇相关出版物进行分析。使用Citespace软件进行国家、机构、期刊、作者的共现分析以及关键词分析。对中医证候出版物有贡献的高产机构和高影响力作者集中在中国。自2012年以来,在一些开创性出版物的推动下,中医证候文献数量迅速增加。根据文献计量学和内容分析结果,过去15年中医证候的研究热点可归纳为六个方面:(a)中医四诊客观化研究;(b)用于中医证候本质研究的组学技术;(c)中医证候评价量表研究;(d)用于中医证候本质研究的宏基因组学技术;(e)中医辨证的数据挖掘技术;(f)慢性乙型肝炎中医证候的系统研究。根据最新的关键词突现情况可识别出新兴趋势:(a)应构建多指标中医证候诊断模型以发展个性化医学。(b)应通过“方证辨证”验证中医证候内涵,筛选出的中医证候潜在标志物需进行临床验证。(c)多学科的干预与融合有望在中医证候研究中找到新突破。