Appel Judith E, van Wijngaarden Els J
Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, Research Group School Psychology and Development in Context KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Research Foundation Flanders, Brussels, Belgium.
Front Psychol. 2021 Oct 21;12:734049. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.734049. eCollection 2021.
In the Netherlands and in Belgium, a political debate emerged regarding the possibility of euthanasia and assisted suicide (EAS) for older adults who experience their lives as completed and no longer worth living, despite being relatively healthy. This mini-review aimed to (1) present an overview of the terms used to denote this phenomenon as well as their definitions and to (2) explore how the underlying experiences are interpreted by the study authors. A systematic search was performed in Web of Science, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and CINAHL, yielding 35 articles meeting the selection criteria. We selected empirical, English-language articles published in peer-reviewed journals. Participants had to have a first-person experience of the phenomenon or be assessed for it, or have a third-person experience of the phenomenon. Results show that the terms tiredness of life (ToL) and weariness of life (WoL) were used most frequently, also in the broader literature on suicidal expressions across the life span. Many studies mentioned operational definitions or synonyms rather than theoretical definitions. Moreover, inside the EAS debate, the term ToL was more common, its definition incorporated death wishes, and it was regularly framed existentially. Outside of this debate, the phenomenon was generally considered as a part of suicidal ideation distinct from death wishes, and its experience was often associated with underlying psychopathology. We discuss the need to establish consensus definitions and conclude that only a multidimensional view may be suitable to capture the complex nature of the phenomenon.
在荷兰和比利时,出现了一场政治辩论,讨论的是对于那些尽管相对健康,但却觉得自己的人生已经完整且不再值得活下去的老年人,实施安乐死和协助自杀(EAS)的可能性。本综述旨在:(1)概述用于表示这一现象的术语及其定义;(2)探讨研究作者如何解读其潜在体验。我们在科学网、医学期刊数据库、心理学文摘数据库和护理学与健康领域数据库中进行了系统检索,共得到35篇符合入选标准的文章。我们选取了发表在同行评审期刊上的实证性英文文章。参与者必须对该现象有第一人称体验或接受过相关评估,或者对该现象有第三人称体验。结果表明,“生活倦怠”(ToL)和“生活疲惫”(WoL)这两个术语使用最为频繁,在关于自杀表达的更广泛的全生命周期文献中也是如此。许多研究提及了操作性定义或同义词而非理论定义。此外,在安乐死和协助自杀的辩论中,“生活倦怠”这一术语更为常见,其定义包含了死亡意愿,并且经常从存在主义角度进行阐述。在这场辩论之外,该现象通常被视为自杀意念的一部分,有别于死亡意愿,其体验往往与潜在的精神病理学相关。我们讨论了建立共识定义的必要性,并得出结论,只有多维视角才可能适合捕捉这一现象的复杂本质。