Alam Asifa, Chaudhry Muhammad Nawaz, Mahmood Adeel, Ahmad Sajid Rashid, Butt Talib-E-
College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan.
Department of Environmental Science and Policy, Faculty of Basic Sciences, Lahore School of Economics, Lahore, Pakistan.
Saudi J Biol Sci. 2021 Nov;28(11):6167-6177. doi: 10.1016/j.sjbs.2021.06.069. Epub 2021 Jun 30.
Dumping sites are the most common types of contaminated lands as they pollute the environment. Environmental management of contaminated sites cannot be delivered effectively and efficiently without robust holistic & integrated risk assessment. Previous studies reveal the absence of a risk assessment model that holistically integrates all essential factors progressively and categorically. The study aimed to develop a holistic & integrated Conceptual Framework Model (CFM) for environmental risk assessment and to apply developed CFM on real-world existing Mahmood Booti Open Dumping Site (MBODS). CFM developed in this study had three main tiers i.e., baseline study, hazard identification & exposure assessment, and risk estimation. For the application of CFM, baseline data were collected and assessed. Water, leachate & soil samples were collected within 1000 m across the site and analyzed for physio-chemical parameters and heavy metals to estimate risk. Results of applied CFM depicted that Physico-chemical analysis of leachate, water, and soil revealed significant pollution levels. Heavy metal analysis exhibited that Ni, Pb, Mn, and Cr levels exceeded the allowable limits of the "World Health Organization" in leachate, water, and soil samples. It also revealed the existence of metals at the source (dumping site itself), pathway, and receptor of the dumping site. E value for Ni, Pb and Cd from the study area manifested a serious probable risk to ecological integrities. Results for PERI from dumpsite demonstrated a serious ecological risk. It can be concluded that although Mahmood Booti dumping site has been at post-closure stage, it is a momentous source of hazardous toxic contaminants to the nearby inhabitants. The work presented in this paper may reproduce repeatedly to create site-specific risk assessment models of other contaminated lands in a cost-effective, consistent and cohesive manner. Application of CFM at Mahmood Booti Dumping site described detailed risk assessment which helps further in risk management.
垃圾倾倒场是最常见的受污染土地类型,因为它们会污染环境。如果没有强大的整体与综合风险评估,就无法有效且高效地对受污染场地进行环境管理。先前的研究表明,缺乏一个能逐步且分类地全面整合所有关键因素的风险评估模型。本研究旨在开发一个用于环境风险评估的整体与综合概念框架模型(CFM),并将所开发的CFM应用于现实世界中现有的马哈茂德·布蒂露天垃圾倾倒场(MBODS)。本研究中开发的CFM有三个主要层级,即基线研究、危害识别与暴露评估以及风险估计。为了应用CFM,收集并评估了基线数据。在场地周围1000米范围内采集了水、渗滤液和土壤样本,并对其进行物理化学参数和重金属分析以估计风险。应用CFM的结果表明,渗滤液、水和土壤的物理化学分析显示出显著的污染水平。重金属分析表明,渗滤液、水和土壤样本中的镍、铅、锰和铬含量超过了“世界卫生组织”的允许限值。研究还揭示了倾倒场源头(倾倒场本身)、路径和受体中金属的存在。研究区域中镍、铅和镉的E值表明对生态完整性存在严重的潜在风险。倾倒场的PERI结果显示存在严重的生态风险。可以得出结论,尽管马哈茂德·布蒂垃圾倾倒场已处于关闭后阶段,但它仍然是附近居民有害有毒污染物的重要来源。本文所开展的工作可以反复进行,以经济高效、一致且连贯的方式创建其他受污染土地的特定场地风险评估模型。在马哈茂德·布蒂垃圾倾倒场应用CFM描述了详细的风险评估,这有助于进一步进行风险管理。