Broc Lucie, Brassart Elise, Bragard Anne, Olive Thierry, Schelstraete Marie-Anne
Université de Poitiers, Université de Tours and CNRS, Tours, France.
Université Côte d'Azur and CNRS, Nice, France.
Front Psychol. 2021 Oct 26;12:721283. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.721283. eCollection 2021.
Narratives of personal experiences emerge early in language acquisition and are particularly commonly experienced in children's daily lives. To produce these stories, children need to develop narrative, linguistic, and social-cognitive skills. Research has shown that these skills are impaired in children with developmental language disorder (DLD) and high functioning autism (HFA). This study aimed to determine whether narrative skills are still impaired in adolescence and to highlight the language similarities and differences between teenagers with DLD and HFA in the production of a narrative of a personal experience. Ten teenagers with DLD, 10 teenagers with HFA and 10 typically developing (TD) teenagers, matched on chronological age, told a narrative of a personal experience. These stories were analyzed to evaluate narrative skills through coherence (respect of the narrative schema) and cohesion (anaphora and connectors) and social-cognitive skills (affective and cognitive mental states of the characters, and arbitrary vocalizations such as voice noises). Teenagers with DLD were less compliant with the complication step in the narrative schema than teenagers with HFA or TD. No difference was observed between the three groups of teenagers in terms of cohesion or regarding the positive and negative social-cognitive skills used in narratives. When producing a narrative of a personal experience, HFA teens do not have difficulties neither with narrative skills and with social-cognitive skills assessed in this paper. In DLD the profile of the teens is not the same: They do not have difficulties with social-cognitive skills and with a part of narrative skills (cohesion), and they have difficulties with the narrative schema.
个人经历叙事在语言习得早期就会出现,并且在儿童日常生活中尤为常见。为了讲述这些故事,儿童需要发展叙事、语言和社会认知技能。研究表明,这些技能在患有发育性语言障碍(DLD)和高功能自闭症(HFA)的儿童中会受到损害。本研究旨在确定叙事技能在青少年时期是否仍然受损,并突出患有DLD和HFA的青少年在讲述个人经历叙事时语言上的异同。十名患有DLD的青少年、十名患有HFA的青少年和十名发育正常(TD)的青少年,年龄匹配,讲述了一段个人经历。对这些故事进行分析,通过连贯性(对叙事模式的遵循)和衔接性(指代和连接词)来评估叙事技能,以及社会认知技能(角色的情感和认知心理状态,以及诸如语音噪音等随意发声)。与患有HFA或TD的青少年相比,患有DLD的青少年在叙事模式中对复杂化步骤的遵循程度较低。在衔接性方面,或者在叙事中使用的积极和消极社会认知技能方面,三组青少年之间没有观察到差异。在讲述个人经历叙事时,患有HFA的青少年在本文评估的叙事技能和社会认知技能方面都没有困难。在DLD中,青少年的情况不同:他们在社会认知技能和部分叙事技能(衔接性)方面没有困难,但在叙事模式方面存在困难。