Adjunct Professor, Department of Foundational Sciences, Oakland University William Beaumont School of Medicine.
Associate Professor of Medicine and College Mentor, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center at El Paso, Paul L. Foster School of Medicine.
MedEdPORTAL. 2021 Oct 22;17:11197. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.11197. eCollection 2021.
is an open-access journal for health professions educators to publish their educational activities. The Educational Summary Report (ESR) is the manuscript that represents scholarly expression of those activities, aligned with Glassick's criteria for scholarship; however, prospective authors face challenges in writing ESRs, which can lead to rejection.
We developed a conference workshop to teach health professions educators how to write an ESR by reviewing a sample ESR in small groups. The workshop began with a didactic on best practices in crafting each section of an ESR. We then divided participants into small groups to review an assigned section of a sample ESR using a reviewer's checklist and completing a templated flip chart. Each small group then reported out in a large-group discussion. A conference evaluation was distributed online to solicit perceptions of the workshop's effectiveness.
The 90-minute workshop was presented by separate teams of two facilitators at three national conferences. Approximately 35 participants attended the first workshop, and 50 attended the second and third workshops. Survey feedback from 19 respondents (38%) to the evaluation survey at the third workshop was representative of the previous two iterations and demonstrated that workshop content and materials were helpful.
A workshop enabling educators to serve as group peer reviewers of a sample ESR for a submission was well received. Associate editors, faculty mentors, and other experienced faculty development leaders can use these materials to support future authors in submitting to while providing opportunities for national presentations.
是一本开放获取的期刊,面向健康专业教育工作者,供其发表教育活动。教育总结报告(ESR)是代表这些活动的学术表达的稿件,与格拉斯里克的学术标准一致;然而,潜在作者在撰写 ESR 时面临挑战,这可能导致被拒绝。
我们开发了一个会议研讨会,通过在小团体中审查示例 ESR,来教授健康专业教育工作者如何撰写 ESR。研讨会首先介绍了制作 ESR 每个部分的最佳实践的讲座。然后,我们将参与者分成小组,使用评审员检查表和完成模板翻转图表来审查示例 ESR 的指定部分。然后,每个小组在大组讨论中汇报。在线分发会议评估,以征求对研讨会效果的看法。
该 90 分钟的研讨会由两组独立的主持人在三个全国会议上进行。大约有 35 名参与者参加了第一次研讨会,50 名参与者参加了第二次和第三次研讨会。第三次研讨会的 19 名受访者(38%)对评估调查的反馈代表了前两次迭代,并表明研讨会的内容和材料很有帮助。
一个研讨会使教育工作者能够对提交的示例 ESR 进行小组同行评审,这是受欢迎的。副编辑、教师导师和其他经验丰富的教师发展领导者可以使用这些材料来支持未来提交给 的作者,同时提供全国演讲的机会。