Comings D E, Comings B G
Department of Medical Genetics, City of Hope National Medical Center, CA 91010.
Am J Hum Genet. 1987 Nov;41(5):782-803.
To determine the frequency of obsessive, compulsive, and schizoid behaviors in Tourette syndrome (TS), we prospectively questioned 246 patients with TS, 17 with attention-deficit disorder (ADD), 15 with ADD due to a TS gene, and 47 random controls. The comparative frequency of obsessive, compulsive, and repetitive behaviors--such as obsessive unpleasant thoughts, obsessive silly thoughts, echolalia, palilalia, touching things excessively, touching things a specific number of times, touching others excessively, sexual touching, biting or hurting oneself, head banging, rocking, mimicking others, counting things, and occasional or frequent public exhibitionism--were significantly more common in TS patients than in controls. The frequency of each of these was much higher for grade 3 (severe) TS. Most of these behaviors also occurred significantly more often in individuals with ADD or in individuals with ADD secondary to TS (ADD 2(0) TS). When these features were combined into an obsessive-compulsive score, 45.4% of TS patients had a score of 4-15, whereas 8.5% of controls had a score of 4 or 5. These results indicate that obsessive-compulsive behaviors are an integral part of the expression of the TS gene and can be inherited as an autosomal dominant trait. Schizoid symptoms, such as thinking that people were watching them or plotting against them, were significantly more common in TS patients than in controls. Auditory hallucinations of hearing voices were present in 14.6% of TS patients, compared with 2.1% of controls (P = .02). These symptoms were absent in ADD patients but present in ADD 2(0) TS patients. These voices were often blamed for telling them to do bad things and were frequently identified with the devil. None of the controls had a total schizoid behavior score greater than 3, whereas 10.9% of the TS patients had scores of 4-10 (P = .02). This frequency increased to 20.6% in the grade 3 TS patients. These quantitative results confirm our clinical impression that some TS patients have paranoid ideations, often feel that people are out to get them, and hear voices.
为了确定抽动秽语综合征(TS)中强迫、强迫行为和类精神分裂行为的发生频率,我们前瞻性地询问了246例TS患者、17例注意力缺陷障碍(ADD)患者、15例因TS基因导致ADD的患者以及47例随机对照者。强迫、强迫行为及重复行为,如强迫性不愉快想法、强迫性愚蠢想法、模仿言语、重复言语、过度触摸物品、特定次数触摸物品、过度触摸他人、性触摸、咬或伤害自己、撞头、摇晃身体、模仿他人、计数物品以及偶尔或频繁的露阴行为等,在TS患者中的出现频率显著高于对照组。在3级(重度)TS患者中,上述每种行为的发生频率都更高。这些行为中的大多数在ADD患者或继发于TS的ADD(ADD 2(0) TS)患者中也显著更频繁地出现。当将这些特征合并为一个强迫行为评分时,45.4%的TS患者评分在4 - 15分之间,而8.5%的对照组患者评分在4分或5分及以上。这些结果表明,强迫行为是TS基因表达的一个组成部分,并且可以作为常染色体显性性状遗传。类精神分裂症状,如觉得有人在监视他们或阴谋对付他们,在TS患者中比在对照组中显著更常见。14.6%的TS患者存在幻听,而对照组为2.1%(P = .02)。这些症状在ADD患者中不存在,但在ADD 2(0) TS患者中存在。这些声音常被指责让他们做坏事,并且常被认为与魔鬼有关。没有对照组患者的类精神分裂行为总分超过3分,而10.9%的TS患者评分在4 - 10分之间(P = .02)。在3级TS患者中,这一频率增加到20.6%。这些定量结果证实了我们的临床印象,即一些TS患者存在偏执观念,常觉得有人想害他们,并且能听到声音。