Research and Development Solutions, Islamabad, Pakistan.
J Pak Med Assoc. 2021 Nov;71(Suppl 7)(11):S67-S69.
Crowdsourcing pools together dispersed information that is considered public knowledge in an area, to form realistic estimates about the area, or to identify new ideas. The technique can be extremely helpful to develop estimates of public health indicators such as catchment area populations or healthcare providers; however, such uses must be scientifically validated.
We divided the community into 1040 discrete segments of similar lengths of streets (called spots) and then randomly selected 605 of these spots for crowdsourcing. Local respondents were asked to estimate the maximum and the minimum population residing in those spots. Five informants were interviewed per spot. Median values for the maximum and minimum were averaged to arrive at an estimate for the spot's population. Estimates for all spots were added together to arrive at the population of the community. One hundred spots from the 597 crowdsourced spots were revisited to conduct a household census as a "gold standard".
Spots where both crowdsourcing and census estimates were computed had a crowdsource population estimate of 19,255 versus a census estimate of 18,119 - a variation of 5.9% (p: <0.001). However, within spot variation was a mean of 25%.
Crowdsourcing communities for public knowledge information can yield more accurate information about public health indicators such as populations. In turn these estimates can help to better understand public health programme coverage. Other applications to consider may be missed children for immunization or schooling, deaths or births in communities or to identify total formal or informal healthcare providers in a community.
众包汇集了分散在某个领域的公共知识信息,以形成对该领域的现实估计,或识别新的想法。该技术对于开发公共卫生指标的估计非常有帮助,例如集水区人口或医疗保健提供者;然而,此类用途必须经过科学验证。
我们将社区划分为 1040 个相似长度的街道离散段(称为点),然后随机选择其中的 605 个点进行众包。当地受访者被要求估计这些点上居住的最大和最小人口。每个点采访了 5 名知情者。对最大和最小的中位数进行平均,得出该点人口的估计值。将所有点的估计值相加,得出社区的人口。从 597 个众包点中随机抽取 100 个点进行家庭普查,作为“黄金标准”。
计算了众包和普查估计值的点的众包人口估计值为 19255,而普查估计值为 18119,差异为 5.9%(p:<0.001)。然而,点内的差异平均值为 25%。
众包社区获取公共知识信息可以更准确地了解人口等公共卫生指标。反过来,这些估计可以帮助更好地了解公共卫生计划的覆盖范围。其他可以考虑的应用可能是错过免疫或上学的儿童、社区内的死亡或出生,或识别社区内的总正式或非正式医疗保健提供者。