Ministry of Health, Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, Ankara, Turkey.
Gulhane Medicine Faculty, University of Health Sciences, Istanbul, Turkey.
Value Health Reg Issues. 2022 May;29:1-7. doi: 10.1016/j.vhri.2021.07.010. Epub 2021 Nov 15.
To date, the economic effects of medical device directives compared with the clinical and regulatory effects have not been sufficiently studied. We believe that the financial obligations and responsibilities imposed on the stakeholders by the legal regulations have a corresponding economic indicator in the medical device market.
In this study, we selected 2 crucial legal regulations on medical devices in Turkey: the Medical Device Directive that has been harmonized from the European Union and the Medical Device Sales, Advertising, and Promotion Directive. The impacts of these regulations on foreign trade were investigated using interrupted time-series analysis. Turkey's monthly medical device export and import data from 2008 to 2019 were obtained under 56 6-digit custom codes.
The results show that the selected directives have significantly affected the foreign trade trend level, and they may be breakpoints in the Turkey's foreign trade trend curve. We also reported the significant differences between the Medical Device Directive and the European Union's new medical device regulation (MDR) (2017/745 MDR).
We concluded that the MDR, which has more strict requirements, will result in increased costs for economic operators in comparison with the current directive and would further increase the import of medical devices by the importing countries. To prevent this, Turkey should aim to have a manufacturer's position by improving their clinical trial capabilities and manufacturing infrastructures with innovation-based approaches.
迄今为止,医疗器械指令的经济影响与临床和监管影响相比尚未得到充分研究。我们认为,法律法规对利益相关者施加的财务义务和责任在医疗器械市场上有相应的经济指标。
在这项研究中,我们选择了土耳其的 2 项关于医疗器械的重要法律法规:已与欧盟协调的医疗器械指令和医疗器械销售、广告和推广指令。使用中断时间序列分析研究这些法规对对外贸易的影响。根据 56 个 6 位海关编码,获得了 2008 年至 2019 年土耳其每月医疗器械出口和进口数据。
结果表明,选定的指令显著影响了对外贸易趋势水平,它们可能是土耳其对外贸易趋势曲线的转折点。我们还报告了医疗器械指令与欧盟新医疗器械法规(MDR)(2017/745 MDR)之间的显著差异。
我们的结论是,与现行指令相比,要求更严格的 MDR 将导致经济经营者的成本增加,并进一步增加医疗器械的进口。为了防止这种情况发生,土耳其应通过创新型方法提高其临床试验能力和制造基础设施,努力取得制造商的地位。