Second Department of Psychiatry, Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology, Sobieskiego 9, 02-957 Warsaw, Poland,
Psychiatr Danub. 2021 Fall;33(3):328-333. doi: 10.24869/psyd.2021.328.
Although the efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) has been well established, the utilization rate of ECT has decreased in Poland in recent years. One of the main reasons could be the negative attitude towards ECT in the community and by mental health professionals. The aim of this study was to assess the knowledge about and attitudes toward ECT in Polish mental health professionals including psychiatrists and non-physicians: nurses, psychologists, social workers.
Psychiatrists and other mental health professionals in two large Polish hospitals were approached to participate in the survey by completing a 28-item questionnaire. The specific hospitals have been selected due to the fact that they were located in the same province of Poland (Mazowsze), had similar catchment area and profile, provided similar mental health services with only one exception; one offered ECT while the other did not. Of the 185 questionnaires that had been distributed, 165 were completed yielding a response rate of 89.19%. The study population consists of 85 psychiatrists and trainees and 80 non-physicians.
Psychiatrists did not differ from other mental health professionals with respect to the knowledge and attitudes toward ECT. However, there were significant differences in the attitude (9.1±3.8 vs 7.1±3.3; p<0.001) and knowledge (5.9±3.8 vs 2.8±4.1; p<0.001) scores between those professionals, who have ever worked in a psychiatric ward where they could observe ECT sessions and those who have not had such an opportunity.
Frequent witnessing of ECT sessions seems to be the most effective educational intervention to change negative attitudes towards ECT.
尽管电抽搐治疗(ECT)的疗效已得到充分证实,但近年来波兰的 ECT 使用率有所下降。其中一个主要原因可能是社区和精神卫生专业人员对 ECT 的负面态度。本研究旨在评估波兰精神卫生专业人员(包括精神科医生和非医师:护士、心理学家、社会工作者)对 ECT 的知识和态度。
通过完成一份 28 项的问卷,联系了两家波兰大医院的精神科医生和其他精神卫生专业人员参与调查。选择这两家特定医院是因为它们位于波兰的同一个省(马佐夫舍省),具有相似的服务人群和特点,提供类似的精神卫生服务,唯一的区别是一家提供 ECT,另一家则不提供。在分发的 185 份问卷中,有 165 份被完成,应答率为 89.19%。研究人群包括 85 名精神科医生和受训者以及 80 名非医师。
精神科医生在对 ECT 的知识和态度方面与其他精神卫生专业人员没有差异。然而,在对 ECT 的态度(9.1±3.8 与 7.1±3.3;p<0.001)和知识(5.9±3.8 与 2.8±4.1;p<0.001)评分方面,那些曾经在能够观察 ECT 治疗的精神科病房工作过的专业人员与那些没有这种机会的专业人员之间存在显著差异。
频繁观察 ECT 治疗似乎是改变对 ECT 负面态度的最有效教育干预措施。