Departament of Sociology 2, University of Alicante, Spain.
Department of Social Sciences, UiT the Arctic University of Norway, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2023 May;51(3):347-354. doi: 10.1177/14034948211056210. Epub 2021 Nov 19.
This study aimed to compare the self-rated health status of the Roma and of the general population by gender and educational level in six Central and Eastern European countries.
We analysed the United Nations Development Program Regional Roma Survey and EUROSTAT's European Union Statistics on Income and Living Conditions surveys from 2011 for Bulgaria, Croatia, Czechia, Hungary, Romania and Slovakia. Using logistic regression, predicted probabilities of good or very good self-rated health were estimated for the Roma (=11,401), Roma neighbours (=5857) and the general population (=101,579) stratified by gender, and adjusted by age, country and educational level.
There was a distinctive social gradient in self-rated health between the groups among both men and women, and a gap between primary versus secondary or tertiary education among all three groups, but Roma (men) and their neighbours with secondary or higher education had significantly worse predicted self-rated health compared to the general population with similar qualifications.
These results strongly suggest that ethnicity and gender should be considered as fundamental causes that explain structural health inequalities. Consequently, future research and policy initiatives to reduce health inequities should acknowledge the impact of ethnic minorities and how these fundamental causes extend the general population's social gradient in health. Study designs enabling direct comparisons between ethnic groups and the general population should be applied. More and better data about ethnic minorities are needed to document and monitor existing health inequalities.
本研究旨在比较 6 个中东欧国家中罗姆人和一般人群的自感健康状况,并按性别和教育程度进行分层。
我们分析了联合国开发计划署的区域罗姆人调查和欧盟统计局的 2011 年欧盟收入和生活条件调查的数据。采用逻辑回归,根据性别对罗姆人(=11401 人)、罗姆人邻居(=5857 人)和一般人群(=101579 人)进行分层,调整年龄、国家和教育程度,估计良好或非常良好自感健康的预测概率。
无论男女,各群体之间的自感健康状况均存在明显的社会梯度差异,而且所有三组人群中,小学教育与中学或高等教育之间存在差距,但与具有同等学历的一般人群相比,罗姆人(男性)及其具有中学或高等教育程度的邻居的预测自感健康状况明显较差。
这些结果强烈表明,种族和性别应被视为解释结构性健康不平等的根本原因。因此,未来旨在减少健康不平等的研究和政策举措应承认少数民族的影响,以及这些根本原因如何扩大一般人群的健康社会梯度。应采用能够在族裔群体和一般人群之间进行直接比较的研究设计。需要更多更好的少数民族数据来记录和监测现有的健康不平等。