Behavioural Science Institute, Radboud Universiteit, Nijmegen, Netherlands.
Radboud Universiteit, Nijmegen, Netherlands.
Ann Dyslexia. 2022 Jul;72(2):341-360. doi: 10.1007/s11881-021-00246-w. Epub 2021 Nov 19.
The use of adequate reading comprehension strategies is important to read efficiently. Students with dyslexia not only read slower and less accurately, they also use fewer reading comprehension strategies. To compensate for their decoding problems, they often receive audio-support (narration written text). However, audio-support linearly guides readers from beginning to end through texts, possibly hindering the use of reading comprehension strategies in expository texts and negatively impacting reading time and reading comprehension performance. We examined to what extent audio-support affects reading comprehension strategies, reading times, and reading comprehension performance in 21 secondary school students with dyslexia and 22 typically developing controls. Participants were provided with three types of assignments (summarizing, open-ended questions, statement questions) in each condition (written text with and without audio-support). SMI RED-500 eye tracker captured eye movements during reading. The standard deviation of the weighted fixation duration times on the three paragraphs was considered indicative of the disparity of readers' attention within the text. Following a discrimination based on experts' reading behavior and hand-coded validation, these scores visualized whether students used the intensive reading strategy (reading whole text) or selective reading strategy (focusing on part of the text). In open-ended assignments, students divided their attention more over the whole text instead of focusing on one specific part when audio was added. In addition, audio-support increased reading time in students with and without dyslexia in most tasks, while in neither of the tasks audio-support affected reading comprehension performance. Audio-support impacts reading comprehension strategy and reading time in all students.
使用适当的阅读理解策略对于高效阅读非常重要。阅读障碍的学生不仅阅读速度较慢且准确性较低,而且使用的阅读理解策略也较少。为了弥补解码问题,他们通常会接受音频支持(将文本朗读出来)。然而,音频支持会线性地引导读者从头到尾阅读文本,这可能会阻碍他们在说明文阅读中使用阅读理解策略,并对阅读时间和阅读理解表现产生负面影响。我们研究了在 21 名阅读障碍的中学生和 22 名典型发展的对照组中,音频支持对阅读理解策略、阅读时间和阅读理解表现的影响程度。参与者在每种条件下(有和没有音频支持的书面文本)完成了三种类型的任务(总结、开放式问题、陈述式问题)。SMI RED-500 眼动追踪仪在阅读过程中捕获了眼动。在三个段落上加权注视持续时间的标准差被认为是读者在文本内注意力差异的指标。根据专家的阅读行为和手动编码验证进行区分后,这些分数可以可视化学生是否使用了精读策略(阅读整篇文本)或选读策略(关注文本的一部分)。在开放式任务中,当添加音频时,学生在整个文本上的注意力会更加分散,而不是只关注一个特定的部分。此外,在大多数任务中,音频支持都会增加阅读障碍和非阅读障碍学生的阅读时间,但在这两个任务中,音频支持都没有影响阅读理解表现。音频支持会影响所有学生的阅读理解策略和阅读时间。