Knoop-van Campen Carolien A N, Segers Eliane, Verhoeven Ludo
Behavioural Science Institute, Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Department of Instructional Technology, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands.
Dyslexia. 2018 May;24(2):140-155. doi: 10.1002/dys.1585. Epub 2018 Mar 25.
The present study aimed to examine the modality and redundancy effects in multimedia learning in children with dyslexia in order to find out whether their learning benefits from written and/or spoken text with pictures. We compared study time and knowledge gain in 26 11-year-old children with dyslexia and 38 typically reading peers in a within-subjects design. All children were presented with a series of user-paced multimedia lessons in 3 conditions: pictorial information presented with (a) written text, (b) audio, or (c) combined text and audio. We also examined whether children's learning outcomes were related to their working memory. With respect to study time, we found modality and reversed redundancy effects. Children with dyslexia spent more time learning in the text condition, compared with the audio condition and the combined text-and-audio condition. Regarding knowledge gain, no modality or redundancy effects were evidenced. Although the groups differed on working memory, it did not influence the modality or redundancy effect on study time or knowledge gain. In multimedia learning, it thus is more efficient to provide children with dyslexia with audio or with auditory support.
本研究旨在考察阅读障碍儿童在多媒体学习中的模态和冗余效应,以确定他们的学习是否受益于配有图片的书面和/或口头文本。我们采用被试内设计,比较了26名11岁阅读障碍儿童和38名阅读正常的同龄人在学习时间和知识获取方面的差异。所有儿童都在三种条件下接受了一系列由用户自主控制进度的多媒体课程:(a)配有书面文本的图片信息、(b)音频、或(c)文本与音频相结合。我们还研究了儿童的学习成果是否与他们的工作记忆有关。在学习时间方面,我们发现了模态和反向冗余效应。与音频条件和文本与音频相结合的条件相比,阅读障碍儿童在文本条件下花费更多时间学习。在知识获取方面,未发现模态或冗余效应。尽管两组在工作记忆方面存在差异,但这并未影响学习时间或知识获取的模态或冗余效应。因此,在多媒体学习中,为阅读障碍儿童提供音频或听觉支持效率更高。