Howe G R, Nair R C, Newcombe H B, Miller A B, Burch J D, Abbatt J D
National Cancer Institute of Canada, University of Toronto, Ontario.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1987 Dec;79(6):1255-60.
A cohort study of 2,103 workers employed between 1942 and 1960 at a uranium mine in the Northwest Territories, Canada, was conducted. A total of 57 lung cancer deaths was observed (expected = 24.73, P less than .0001). There was a highly significant linear relationship between exposure and increased risk of lung cancer, giving estimates for the relative and attributable risk coefficients of 0.27 per working level month (WLM) and 3.10 per WLM per 10(6) person-years. These risk coefficients were substantially less than those estimated from the experience of miners in the Beaverlodge mine, which have previously been reported. Any biases in the present estimates are likely to have been upward, and therefore they probably represent an upper limit. The major difference between the two mine cohorts is in the exposure rate, since the Port Radium miners were exposed to much greater concentrations of radon daughters than the Beaverlodge miners. It is postulated that risk of lung cancer from radon daughter exposure may be modified by exposure rate, for which hypothesis there is some support from other epidemiologic data.
对1942年至1960年间受雇于加拿大西北地区一座铀矿的2103名工人进行了一项队列研究。共观察到57例肺癌死亡(预期数=24.73,P<0.0001)。暴露与肺癌风险增加之间存在高度显著的线性关系,得出每工作水平月(WLM)的相对风险系数和归因风险系数估计值分别为0.27和每10^6人年每WLM 3.10。这些风险系数显著低于先前报道的比弗洛吉矿矿工经验所估计的值。目前估计中的任何偏差可能都是向上的,因此它们可能代表上限。两个矿队列之间的主要差异在于暴露率,因为镭港矿的矿工接触氡子体的浓度比比弗洛吉矿的矿工高得多。据推测,氡子体暴露导致的肺癌风险可能会因暴露率而改变,这一假设得到了其他流行病学数据的一些支持。