1DATA Consortium, www.1DATA.life, Olathe, United States.
Department of Mathematics, Kansas State University, Kansas City, United States.
Elife. 2021 Nov 23;10:e70734. doi: 10.7554/eLife.70734.
Potential therapy and confounding factors including typical co-administered medications, patient's disease states, disease prevalence, patient demographics, medical histories, and reasons for prescribing a drug often are incomplete, conflicting, missing, or uncharacterized in spontaneous adverse drug event (ADE) reporting systems. These missing or incomplete features can affect and limit the application of quantitative methods in pharmacovigilance for meta-analyses of data during randomized clinical trials.
Data from patients with hypertension were retrieved and integrated from the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System; 134 antihypertensive drugs out of 1131 drugs were filtered and then evaluated using the empirical Bayes geometric mean (EBGM) of the posterior distribution to build ADE-drug profiles with an emphasis on the pulmonary ADEs. Afterward, the graphical least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (GLASSO) captured drug associations based on pulmonary ADEs by correcting hidden factors and confounder misclassification. Selected drugs were then compared using the Friedman test in drug classes and clusters obtained from GLASSO.
Following multiple filtering stages to exclude insignificant and noise-driven reports, we found that drugs from antihypertensives agents, urologicals, and antithrombotic agents (macitentan, bosentan, epoprostenol, selexipag, sildenafil, tadalafil, and beraprost) form a similar class with a significantly higher incidence of pulmonary ADEs. Macitentan and bosentan were associated with 64% and 56% of pulmonary ADEs, respectively. Because these two medications are prescribed in diseases affecting pulmonary function and may be likely to emerge among the highest reported pulmonary ADEs, in fact, they serve to validate the methods utilized here. Conversely, doxazosin and rilmenidine were found to have the least pulmonary ADEs in selected drugs from hypertension patients. Nifedipine and candesartan were also found by signal detection methods to form a drug cluster, shown by several studies an effective combination of these drugs on lowering blood pressure and appeared an improved side effect profile in comparison with single-agent monotherapy.
We consider pulmonary ADE profiles in multiple long-standing groups of therapeutics including antihypertensive agents, antithrombotic agents, beta-blocking agents, calcium channel blockers, or agents acting on the renin-angiotensin system, in patients with hypertension associated with high risk for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). We found that several individual drugs have significant differences between their drug classes and compared to other drug classes. For instance, macitentan and bosentan from endothelin receptor antagonists show major concern while doxazosin and rilmenidine exhibited the least pulmonary ADEs compared to the outcomes of other drugs. Using techniques in this study, we assessed and confirmed the hypothesis that drugs from the same drug class could have very different pulmonary ADE profiles affecting outcomes in acute respiratory illness.
GJW and MJD accepted funding from BioNexus KC for funding on this project, but BioNexus KC had no direct role in this article.
在自发药物不良反应(ADE)报告系统中,潜在的治疗方法和混杂因素,包括常见的联合用药、患者的疾病状态、疾病流行率、患者人口统计学特征、病史以及开处方的原因,通常是不完整、相互矛盾、缺失或未描述的。这些缺失或不完整的特征会影响和限制定量方法在药物警戒中的应用,以便对随机临床试验期间的数据进行荟萃分析。
从 FDA 不良事件报告系统中检索并整合了高血压患者的数据;从 1131 种药物中筛选出 134 种降压药物,然后使用后验分布的经验贝叶斯几何平均值(EBGM)进行评估,重点关注肺部 ADE。此后,图形最小绝对收缩和选择算子(GLASSO)通过纠正隐藏因素和混杂因素分类错误,基于肺部 ADE 捕捉药物关联。然后,使用 GLASSO 获得的药物类和聚类中对选定药物进行 Friedman 检验。
经过多次过滤阶段以排除无意义和噪声驱动的报告,我们发现来自抗高血压药物、泌尿科药物和抗血栓形成药物(马西替坦、波生坦、依前列醇、塞来昔帕、西地那非、他达拉非和贝前列素)的药物形成了一个具有显著更高肺部 ADE 发生率的相似类别。马西替坦和波生坦分别与 64%和 56%的肺部 ADE 相关。由于这两种药物用于治疗影响肺功能的疾病,并且可能是报告的最高肺部 ADE 中最常见的药物,因此它们实际上验证了这里使用的方法。相反,多沙唑嗪和雷米普利嗪在高血压患者中选定的药物中发现肺部 ADE 最少。硝苯地平和坎地沙坦也被信号检测方法发现形成了一个药物群集,多项研究表明这些药物联合使用对降低血压有显著效果,与单一药物治疗相比,副作用谱有改善。
我们考虑了包括抗高血压药物、抗血栓形成药物、β受体阻滞剂、钙通道阻滞剂或作用于肾素-血管紧张素系统的药物在内的多种长期治疗药物组中的肺部 ADE 概况,这些药物与患有高血压的患者相关,这些患者有患 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)的高风险。我们发现,一些单一药物在药物类别之间存在显著差异,与其他药物类别相比也存在显著差异。例如,内皮素受体拮抗剂中的马西替坦和波生坦引起了极大关注,而多沙唑嗪和雷米普利嗪与其他药物的结果相比,肺部 ADE 最少。在这项研究中,我们使用了技术评估并证实了这一假设,即来自同一药物类别的药物可能具有非常不同的肺部 ADE 概况,从而影响急性呼吸道疾病的结果。
GJW 和 MJD 接受了 BioNexus KC 为该项目提供的资金,但 BioNexus KC 在本文中没有直接作用。