Department of Psychology, Neuro-Mi, Milan Center for Neuroscience, University of Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy.
PLoS One. 2021 Nov 24;16(11):e0260540. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0260540. eCollection 2021.
The present study used EEG/ERPs to detect the activation of implicit stereotypical representations associated to other-race (OR) people and the modulation of such activation through the previous presentation of positive vs. neutral social information. Electrophysiological signals were recorded in 40 Italian Caucasian participants, unaware of the overall study's purpose. They were presented with 285 sentences that could either violate, non-violate (e.g., "the Roma girl was involved in a robbery) or be neutral with regard to stereotypical concepts concerning other-race people (e.g. Asians, Africans, Arabic). ERPs were time-locked to the terminal words. Prior to the sentence reading task, participants were exposed to a 10 minutes colourful video documentary. While the experimental group was presented a video containing images picturing other-race characters involved in "prestigious" activities that violated stereotypical negative assumptions (e.g. a black neurosurgeon leading a surgery team), the control group viewed a neutral documentary about flora and fauna. EEG signals were then recorded during the sentence reading task to explore whether the previous exposure to the experimental video could modulate the detection of incongruence in the sentences violating stereotypes, as marked by the N400 response. A fictitious task was adopted, consisted in detecting rare animal names. Indeed, only the control group showed a greater N400 response (350-550 ms) to words incongruent with ethnic stereotypes compared to congruent and neutral ones, thus suggesting the presence of a racial bias. No N400 response was found for the experimental group, suggesting a lack of negative expectation for OR individuals. The swLORETA inverse solution, performed on the prejudice-related N400 showed that the Inferior Temporal and the Superior and Middle Frontal Gyri were the strongest N400 intra-cortical sources. Regardless of the experimental manipulation, Congruent terminal words evoked a greater P300 response (500-600 ms) compared to incongruent and neutral ones and a late frontal positivity (650-800 ms) was found to be larger to sentences involving OR than own-race characters (either congruent or incongruent with the prejudice) thus possibly indicating bias-free perceptual in-group/out-group categorization processes. The data showed how it is possible to modulate a pre-existing racial prejudice (as reflected by N400 effect) through exposure to positive media-driven information about OR people. Further follow-up studies should determine the duration in time, and across contexts, of this modulatory effect.
本研究使用 EEG/ERPs 来检测与异族(OR)人相关的内隐刻板印象的激活,以及通过先前呈现积极与中性社会信息来调节这种激活。电生理信号记录在 40 名意大利白种高加索参与者身上,他们并不知道整个研究的目的。他们被呈现了 285 个句子,这些句子可能违反、不违反(例如,“罗姆女孩参与了抢劫”)或与关于异族的刻板概念中性(例如亚洲人、非洲人、阿拉伯人)。ERP 与终端词同步。在句子阅读任务之前,参与者观看了十分钟彩色纪录片。在实验组观看了一个包含描绘参与“有声望”活动的异族角色的图像的视频,这些活动违反了刻板的负面假设(例如,一名黑人神经外科医生领导一个手术团队),而对照组观看了一个关于动植物的中性纪录片。然后,在句子阅读任务期间记录 EEG 信号,以探讨先前暴露于实验视频是否可以调节对违反刻板印象的句子的不和谐性的检测,如 N400 反应所标记。采用了一个虚构的任务,包括检测稀有动物的名称。事实上,只有对照组在与种族刻板印象不一致的单词上显示出更大的 N400 反应(350-550ms),与一致和中性的单词相比,这表明存在种族偏见。实验组没有发现 N400 反应,这表明对 OR 个体没有负面预期。针对与偏见相关的 N400 进行了 swLORETA 反演求解,结果表明,下颞叶和上、中额回是最强的 N400 皮质内源。无论实验操作如何,与不一致和中性的终端词相比,一致的终端词都能引起更大的 P300 反应(500-600ms),并且发现与异族(无论是与偏见一致还是不一致)相比,晚额叶正波(650-800ms)更大,这可能表明对感知内群体/外群体的分类过程没有偏见。数据表明,通过接触关于 OR 人的积极媒体驱动信息,如何调节预先存在的种族偏见(如 N400 效应所反映的)。进一步的后续研究应确定这种调节效应的时间持续时间和跨情境持续时间。