Department of Physiology, Institute of Biological Sciences, Federal University of Juiz de Fora, Juiz de Fora 36036-900, Brazil.
Exercise Science, Health and Human Performance Research Group, Department of Sport Sciences, Institute of Health Sciences, Federal University of Triangulo Mineiro, Uberaba 38025-180, Brazil.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Nov 13;18(22):11914. doi: 10.3390/ijerph182211914.
Instagram (IG) reaches millions of people, sharing personal content and all kinds of information, including those related to exercise and health. However, the scientific quality of the posted information is questionable. Thus, this study aimed to analyze whether exercise and health information posted by popular Brazilian IG influencers has technical-scientific accuracy. A personal IG account was created to identify Brazilian IG profiles. The inclusion criteria of the accounts were: (1) having 50% of all the shared posts related to topics about exercise and health, such as nutrition, health and wellness, medicine, or physical fitness; and (2) having over 100,000 followers. Qualitative analysis revealed a low quality percentage (38.79 ± 25.43%) for all analyzed posts. Out of all the posts, only 13 (~2.7%) cited a reference endorsing the information. Moreover, the higher quality-ratio score of the posts was not directly associated with the higher educational qualification of the influencers (r = 0.313; = 0.076). Nevertheless, the number of followers was inversely correlated with the educational qualification of the influencers (r = -0.450; = 0.009), but not with the quality-ratio score of the posts (r = -0.178 = 0.322). We conclude that prominent Brazilian IG influencers disseminate low-quality information about exercise and health, contributing to the wide-spreading of misinformation to millions of followers.
Instagram(IG)拥有数以百万计的用户,分享个人内容和各种信息,包括与锻炼和健康相关的信息。然而,这些信息的科学质量值得怀疑。因此,本研究旨在分析巴西流行的 IG 影响者发布的锻炼和健康信息是否具有技术科学性。创建了一个个人 IG 账户来识别巴西 IG 个人资料。账户的纳入标准为:(1)分享的帖子中有 50%与锻炼和健康相关的主题,如营养、健康和保健、医学或健身;(2)拥有超过 100,000 名关注者。定性分析显示,所有分析帖子的质量百分比都很低(38.79±25.43%)。在所有帖子中,只有 13 个(约 2.7%)引用了支持信息的参考文献。此外,帖子的高质量比评分与影响者的教育背景没有直接关联(r=0.313,p=0.076)。然而,关注者的数量与影响者的教育背景呈负相关(r=-0.450,p=0.009),但与帖子的高质量比评分无关(r=-0.178,p=0.322)。我们的结论是,著名的巴西 IG 影响者传播有关锻炼和健康的低质量信息,导致错误信息广泛传播给数以百万计的关注者。