Less Elyse Levine, Mady Melissa, Beckman Kara J, Kingsbury John H
Tobacco-Free Alliance, St. Paul, MN, USA.
University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Health Promot Pract. 2022 Nov;23(6):1028-1038. doi: 10.1177/15248399211045353. Epub 2021 Dec 1.
Youth e-cigarette use or "vaping" has increased substantially in the past few years, an escalation attributable to flavored "pod mod" e-cigarette devices that deliver higher levels of nicotine compared with free-base nicotine found in other types of e-cigarettes. Use rates, addiction, and harms are alarming as negative effects from nicotine on adolescent brain development are well documented, and e-cigarette use is predictive of cigarette smoking initiation. This qualitative study examined what drives the appeal of these products through 10 focus groups conducted in 2019 with 67 Minnesota high school students. Focus groups aimed to understand students' personal experiences and contextual factors that may contribute to current vaping trends and explore opportunities for improved prevention messaging. Study results revealed participants' divergent perceptions of tobacco products (i.e., vaping vs. e-cigarettes vs. cigarettes) and the benefits and harms of each product. Participants provided insights into why youth vape, describing vaping as an easily accessible coping method to help teens manage stress and anxiety. Peer normalization and invincibility beliefs about harms were also present. Participants generated ideas about prevention messaging, describing the ineffectiveness of prevention messages they currently receive, and expressing the need for accurate information about e-cigarette health risks presented in personalized, nonjudgmental contexts by people they know care about them. These results have clear implications for prevention initiatives and can be used to inform effective prevention strategies, messaging, programming, and policies, some of which are specific to e-cigarette prevention and others that align with the theory of positive youth development.
在过去几年中,青少年电子烟使用或“雾化吸”现象大幅增加,这种情况的升级归因于口味各异的“盒式模组”电子烟设备,与其他类型电子烟中的游离碱尼古丁相比,这些设备会释放更高含量的尼古丁。鉴于尼古丁对青少年大脑发育的负面影响已有充分记录,且电子烟使用可预测吸烟行为的开始,其使用率、成瘾性及危害令人担忧。这项定性研究通过2019年对67名明尼苏达州高中生进行的10个焦点小组讨论,探究了这些产品具有吸引力的原因。焦点小组旨在了解学生的个人经历以及可能导致当前雾化吸趋势的背景因素,并探索改进预防宣传信息的机会。研究结果揭示了参与者对烟草产品(即雾化吸产品、电子烟与香烟)的不同认知,以及每种产品的利弊。参与者深入探讨了青少年使用电子烟的原因,将其描述为一种便于获取的应对方式,有助于青少年应对压力和焦虑。同龄人对危害的认同以及对自身免疫的信念也存在。参与者提出了有关预防宣传信息的想法,描述了他们目前收到的预防信息的无效性,并表示需要由他们认识且关心他们的人在个性化、无评判的背景下提供有关电子烟健康风险的准确信息。这些结果对预防举措具有明确的启示意义,可用于为有效的预防策略、宣传信息、项目和政策提供参考,其中一些特定于电子烟预防,另一些则与积极的青少年发展理论相一致。