University of Edinburgh, UK.
George Mason University, Fairfax, VA, USA.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2023 Aug;67(10-11):1017-1036. doi: 10.1177/0306624X211062161. Epub 2021 Dec 1.
Identifying the self-perceptions of child sexual exploitation material (CSEM) consumers compared to a reference population of non-consumers is critical in establishing distorted cognitions that may not be elucidated when comparison is made with groups who have committed other offenses. This exploratory work utilizes a quantitative approach toward identifying how individuals previously convicted of child pornography offenses view CSEM and CSEM offending, using a group of non-offenders as a baseline. The target group was selected based on their inclusion in two sex offender registries for child pornography offenses ( = 78). A reference group of non-offenders ( = 254) was gender-matched from a subset of a prior study evaluating the public perceptions of CSEM. Both groups were adults located within the United States and were asked questions using an online survey about their general perceptions of CSEM, their endorsement of CSEM beliefs, and their opinions related to the legality of various forms of CSEM and associated laws and sentencing guidelines. The study found that CSEM consumers more accurately assessed risks associated with CSEM offending, but that they exhibited potential minimization-based cognitive distortions related to severity and victimization and more strongly endorsed child erotica and virtual child pornography being legal. Additionally, they endorsed treatment over prison, and were strongly opposed to sex offender registration for child pornography offenses. The results provide potential treatment targets, including behavioral areas that may be pathways to CSEM offending.
识别儿童性剥削材料(CSEM)消费者与非消费者的自我认知对比,对于确定可能无法通过与其他犯罪群体进行比较而阐明的扭曲认知至关重要。这项探索性工作采用定量方法,确定以前被判犯有儿童色情制品罪的个人如何看待 CSEM 和 CSEM 犯罪,将非犯罪者作为基线群体。目标群体是根据他们在两个儿童色情制品性犯罪者登记册中的包含情况选择的(n=78)。非犯罪者的参考群体(n=254)是从之前评估公众对 CSEM 看法的一项研究的一个子集中按性别匹配的。两组成年人均位于美国,他们通过在线调查回答了有关他们对 CSEM 的一般看法、对 CSEM 信仰的认可,以及他们对各种形式的 CSEM 及其相关法律和判决准则的合法性的看法。研究发现,CSEM 消费者更准确地评估了与 CSEM 犯罪相关的风险,但他们表现出潜在的基于最小化的认知扭曲,涉及严重性和受害程度,并更强烈地认可儿童色情作品和虚拟儿童色情作品合法化。此外,他们支持治疗而非监禁,并强烈反对对儿童色情制品犯罪进行性犯罪者登记。研究结果提供了潜在的治疗目标,包括可能导致 CSEM 犯罪的行为领域。