Chew Qian Hui, Sim Kang
Research Division, Institute of Mental Health, Singapore.
West Region and Education Office, Institute of Mental Health, Singapore.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2021 Nov 26;12:1371-1377. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S320615. eCollection 2021.
The COVID-19 pandemic has brought about significant changes in the way undergraduate medical education is conducted including psychiatry teaching. In view of sparse data on how the perception of the undergraduate educational environment (EE) is affected by the pandemic, we sought to compare the ratings of EE and learning processes (motivation, engagement, equipping, appreciation of psychiatry) between the 2020 (during pandemic) and 2019 (before pandemic) cohorts of students, and examined how the perception of the EE would influence overall experience within the psychiatry rotation.
The DREEM (Dundee Ready Education Environment Measure) was administered to fourth-year medical undergraduate students undergoing a psychiatry rotation in 2020 during the pandemic and these ratings were compared with those of the preceding cohort in 2019. Students also completed five additional items evaluating various learning processes and overall rating of the posting. Relationships between the DREEM scores, learning processes, and overall effectiveness of rotation were assessed using correlation and mediational analyses.
Altogether, 84 (response rate 93.3%) and 269 (response rate 89.7%) medical undergraduates participated in the study from 2020 and 2019 cohorts, respectively. The 2020 cohort had higher scores on the total DREEM (p = 0.032), academic self-perception DREEM subscale (p = 0.002), felt more engaged (p = 0.043) and better equipped (p = 0.003) compared with the 2019 cohort. Overall, DREEM and subdomain scores correlated significantly with specific learning processes. The direct effect of total DREEM and overall rating of psychiatry posting was significant in mediational analyses.
Our results highlighted that students' perception of the EE remained positive during the pandemic and impacts overall experience of the psychiatry posting. Undergraduate psychiatry training should continually seek to enhance the EE so as to optimize learning through better engagement and equipping of the learners even during the pandemic.
新冠疫情给本科医学教育(包括精神病学教学)的开展方式带来了重大变化。鉴于关于本科教育环境(EE)的认知如何受疫情影响的数据稀少,我们试图比较2020年(疫情期间)和2019年(疫情前)学生群体对教育环境和学习过程(动机、参与度、知识技能培养、对精神病学的欣赏)的评分,并研究教育环境的认知如何影响精神病学轮转期间的整体体验。
在疫情期间,对2020年正在进行精神病学轮转的四年级医学本科生进行了邓迪教育环境量表(DREEM)测评,并将这些评分与2019年前一届学生的评分进行比较。学生们还完成了另外五项评估各种学习过程和轮转总体评分的项目。使用相关性分析和中介分析评估DREEM分数、学习过程与轮转总体有效性之间的关系。
2020年和2019年的学生群体分别有84名(回复率93.3%)和269名(回复率89.7%)医学本科生参与了该研究。与2019年的学生群体相比,2020年的学生群体在DREEM总分上得分更高(p = 0.032),在学术自我认知DREEM子量表上得分更高(p = 0.002),感觉参与度更高(p = 0.043),知识技能培养更好(p = 0.003)。总体而言,DREEM及其子领域分数与特定学习过程显著相关。在中介分析中,DREEM总分和精神病学轮转总体评分的直接效应显著。
我们的结果表明,在疫情期间学生对教育环境的认知仍保持积极,并影响精神病学轮转的整体体验。本科精神病学培训应持续致力于改善教育环境,以便即使在疫情期间也能通过更好地激发学习者的参与度和培养其知识技能来优化学习。