Kefala-Karli Pelagia, Sassis Leandros, Sassi Marina, Zervides Constantinos
School of Medicine, University of Nicosia, 21 Ilia Papakyriakou Street, 2414, Engomi, Nicosia, Cyprus.
Children's Hospital "Agia Sofia", Thivon Ave. and Papadiamantopoulou Street, 11527, Athens, Greece.
Ultrasound J. 2021 Dec 4;13(1):47. doi: 10.1186/s13089-021-00247-1.
Traditional anatomy teaching methods are based on the models and cadaveric dissections, providing fixed views of the anatomical structures. However, in the last few years, the emerging concept of ultrasound-based teaching in anatomy has started to gain ground among medical curricula. This study aims to evaluate the integration of ultrasound as an adjunct tool to traditional anatomy teaching methods and explore students' perceptions of whether ultrasound-based teaching enhances their interest and knowledge of anatomy. A cross-sectional study was carried out among the students of the 6-year undergraduate entry (MD) and 4-year graduate entry (MBBS) program of the University of Nicosia. A questionnaire was distributed to them after the delivery of several twenty minutes ultrasound sessions by an expert in the field during anatomy practicals. The data were analyzed utilizing SPSS software, and the statistical significance was determined as p value < 0.05.
107 MD and 42 MBBS students completed the questionnaire. Both groups agreed that their ultrasound-based learning experience was good or excellent (79.4% MD students; 92.9% MBBS students), that it enhanced their knowledge of anatomy (68.2% MD students; 90.5% MBBS students) and boosted their confidence regarding their examination skills practice (69.2% MD students; 85.7% MBBS students). Although most students desired more time allocated to the ultrasound station (72% MD students; 85.7% MBBS students), they believed that ultrasound-based teaching is a necessary adjunct to the traditional teaching methods of anatomy (89.7% MD students; 92.9% MBBS students).
Overall, MBBS students were more confident about the benefits of ultrasound-based teaching. Most of the students agreed that cross-sectional sessions of traditional teaching and ultrasound-based teaching strengthened their knowledge of anatomy and enhanced their confidence concerning their clinical examination skills. Medical schools should embrace the advantages that ultrasound-based teaching offers in order future doctors to be qualified to utilize ultrasound for procedural and diagnostical purposes.
传统解剖学教学方法基于模型和尸体解剖,提供解剖结构的固定视图。然而,在过去几年中,基于超声的解剖学教学这一新兴概念已开始在医学课程中逐渐流行。本研究旨在评估超声作为传统解剖学教学方法辅助工具的整合情况,并探讨学生对基于超声的教学是否增强了他们对解剖学的兴趣和知识的看法。在尼科西亚大学6年制本科入学(医学博士)和4年制研究生入学(医学学士)项目的学生中进行了一项横断面研究。在解剖实习期间,由该领域的专家进行了几次20分钟的超声课程后,向学生发放了问卷。利用SPSS软件对数据进行分析,将统计学显著性确定为p值<0.05。
107名医学博士和42名医学学士学生完成了问卷。两组均认为他们基于超声的学习体验良好或优秀(79.4%的医学博士学生;92.9%的医学学士学生),认为其增强了解剖学知识(68.2%的医学博士学生;90.5%的医学学士学生),并提高了他们在考试技能练习方面的信心(69.2%的医学博士学生;85.7%的医学学士学生)。尽管大多数学生希望为超声站分配更多时间(72%的医学博士学生;85.7%的医学学士学生),但他们认为基于超声的教学是解剖学传统教学方法的必要辅助(89.7%的医学博士学生;92.9%的医学学士学生)。
总体而言,医学学士学生对基于超声的教学的益处更有信心。大多数学生同意,传统教学和基于超声的教学的横断面课程加强了他们的解剖学知识,并增强了他们对临床检查技能的信心。医学院校应接受基于超声的教学所提供的优势,以便未来的医生有资格将超声用于操作和诊断目的。