Division of Hematology/Oncology, Department of Pediatrics, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
Department of Medicine, Bioethics Research Center, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
J Adolesc Young Adult Oncol. 2022 Oct;11(5):498-505. doi: 10.1089/jayao.2021.0154. Epub 2021 Dec 6.
High-quality communication is a standard of palliative care for adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with cancer. Yet, few studies have characterized the negative communication experiences of AYAs near the end of life (EOL). We performed a secondary analysis of 27 qualitative interviews with bereaved caregivers of AYAs with cancer who died between 2013 and 2016 at 1 of 3 sites. Interviews focused on barriers to optimal EOL care for AYAs. We used thematic analysis using iterative consensus coding to analyze transcripts. Participants were predominantly white (85%), non-Hispanic (93%), and female (74%). Half of the participants were bereaved parents, and 37% were bereaved partners or spouses. Overall, 23/27 (85%) caregivers described at least one negative communication experience related to one of three themes: (1) Insensitivity to patients' needs, preferences, and values; (2) Insufficient discussions of prognosis and/or EOL; and (3) Loss of support from the clinical team near EOL. Both clinician- and patient-related factors contributed to limited EOL discussions. Lack of care continuity related to both clinician factors and systems of care that required new or changing clinical care teams near the EOL. Caregivers report a desire for clinician sensitivity to their needs and values, information about the future, and longitudinal connections with individual clinicians. Clinicians might improve caregivers' EOL experiences by eliciting patient preferences, engaging in EOL discussions, adapting to the AYA's developmental and emotional needs, and demonstrating a commitment to AYAs and caregivers as they approach the EOL.
高质量的沟通是姑息治疗青少年和年轻成人(AYA)癌症患者的标准。然而,很少有研究描述临终(EOL)时 AYA 的负面沟通体验。我们对 2013 年至 2016 年期间在 3 个地点之一去世的 AYA 癌症丧亲护理者的 27 次定性访谈进行了二次分析。访谈重点是 AYA 临终关怀的最佳障碍。我们使用迭代共识编码的主题分析来分析转录本。参与者主要是白人(85%)、非西班牙裔(93%)和女性(74%)。一半的参与者是丧亲的父母,37%是丧亲的伴侣或配偶。总的来说,27 名护理者中的 23 名(85%)描述了至少一次与三个主题之一相关的负面沟通体验:(1)对患者的需求、偏好和价值观不敏感;(2)对预后和/或 EOL 的讨论不足;(3)在 EOL 附近失去临床团队的支持。临床医生和患者相关因素都导致了临终讨论的局限性。与临床医生因素和需要在 EOL 附近更换新的或改变的临床护理团队的护理系统有关的护理连续性缺失。护理者报告希望临床医生对他们的需求和价值观、对未来的信息以及与个别临床医生的纵向联系敏感。临床医生可以通过引出患者的偏好、进行 EOL 讨论、适应 AYA 的发展和情感需求以及在接近 EOL 时表现出对 AYA 和护理者的承诺,来改善护理者的 EOL 体验。