Department of Anatomy, School of Medicine, The University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan.
Radiology Department, Jordan University Hospital, Amman, Jordan.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2021 Dec 10;100(49):e28169. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000028169.
There is a paucity of osteometric standards for sex estimation from unknown skeletal remains in Jordan and the sexual dimorphism of the sternum has not yet been investigated. The aim of this study was to evaluate the sexual dimorphism in sternal measurements using 3D multidetector computed tomography (MDCT), and to assess their reliability for sex estimation in a Jordanian population. A total of 600 MDCT scans (300 males and 300 females) were used and a total of 8 sternal measurements were studied (manubrium length, sternal body length, combined length of manubrium and body, corpus sterni width at 1st and 3rd sternebrae, sternal index and area). Sexual dimorphism was evaluated by means of discriminant function analyses. Significant sexual dimorphism was found mainly in middle-aged and older adults. Including all subjects, multivariate, and stepwise functions gave an overall accuracy of 83.0% and 84.0%, respectively. Additionally, multivariate and stepwise analyses were conducted separately for each age group. The accuracy of sex estimation in multivariate analysis (all variables) varied from 63.2% in the young, and 83.7% in the middle adults to 84.9% for older adults. In stepwise analysis, the highest accuracy rates were provided by only sternal area in young adults (81.6%), and sternal area combined with sternal body length in middle-aged and older adults (84.2% and 85.3%, respectively). The best sex discriminator using univariate analysis (single variable) was sternal area followed by sternal body length (84.0% and 80.8% respectively). Notably, univariate analyses for most variables gave relatively higher classification accuracies in females but were poor at predicting males in the sample (sex bias ranged between -6.4% and -20%). Our data suggest that dimorphism in the human sternum increases with advancing age and separate discriminant functions are needed for each age group in Jordanians. In addition, multivariate and stepwise analyses using sternum gave higher classification accuracies with comparatively lower sex biases compared to univariate analyses.
约旦缺乏用于鉴定未知骨骼遗骸性别的骨骼测量标准,且胸骨的性别二态性尚未得到研究。本研究旨在使用三维多排螺旋 CT(MDCT)评估胸骨测量的性别二态性,并评估其在约旦人群中进行性别鉴定的可靠性。共使用 600 例 MDCT 扫描(300 例男性和 300 例女性),研究了 8 项胸骨测量指标(胸骨柄长度、胸骨体长度、胸骨柄和体部总长度、第 1 肋和第 3 肋胸骨宽度、胸骨指数和胸骨面积)。通过判别函数分析评估性别二态性。主要在中老年人中发现了明显的性别二态性。包括所有受试者、多元和逐步函数的总准确率分别为 83.0%和 84.0%。此外,还分别对每个年龄组进行了多元和逐步分析。多元分析(所有变量)的性别鉴定准确率在年轻人中为 63.2%,在中年人中为 83.7%,在老年人中为 84.9%。在逐步分析中,仅胸骨面积在年轻人中提供了最高的准确率(81.6%),在中年人和老年人中,胸骨面积结合胸骨体长度的准确率分别为 84.2%和 85.3%。使用单变量分析(单一变量)的最佳性别判别器是胸骨面积,其次是胸骨体长度(分别为 84.0%和 80.8%)。值得注意的是,大多数变量的单变量分析在女性中给出了相对较高的分类准确率,但在样本中预测男性的准确率较差(性别偏差范围在-6.4%至-20%之间)。我们的数据表明,人类胸骨的二态性随着年龄的增长而增加,并且需要为每个年龄组分别建立判别函数。此外,与单变量分析相比,使用胸骨的多元和逐步分析具有更高的分类准确率和相对较低的性别偏差。