Center for Education Development and Research in Health Professions (CEDAR), Lifelong Learning, Education and Assessment Research Network (LEARN), University Medical Centre Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands.
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Utrecht University, Utrecht, Netherlands.
Med Educ. 2022 Apr;56(4):418-431. doi: 10.1111/medu.14711. Epub 2022 Jan 9.
The transition from medical student to junior doctor is challenging. Junior doctors need to become part of the physician community of practice (CoP), while dealing with new responsibilities, tasks and expectations. At the same time, they need to learn how to navigate the frontiers and intersections with the other communities of practice that form the Landscape of Practice (LoP). This study aims to understand how junior doctors experience interprofessional collaboration (IPC) and what elements shape these experiences considering their transition to clinical practice.
In this multicentre qualitative study, 13 junior doctors individually drew two rich pictures of IPC experiences, one positive and one negative. A rich picture is a visual representation, a drawing of a particular situation intended to capture the complex and non-verbal elements of an experience. We used semi-structured interviews to deepen the understanding of junior doctors' depicted IPC experiences. We analysed both visual materials and interview transcripts iteratively, for which we adopted an inductive constructivist thematic analysis.
While transitioning into a doctor, junior doctors become foremost members of the physician CoP and shape their professional identity based on perceived values in their physician community. Interprofessional learning occurs implicitly, without input from the interprofessional team. As a result, junior doctors struggle to bridge the gap between themselves and the interprofessional team, preventing IPC learning from developing into an integrative process. This professional isolation leaves junior doctors wandering the landscape of practice without understanding roles, attitudes and expectations of others.
Learning IPC needs to become a collective endeavour and an explicit learning goal, based on multisource feedback to take advantage of the expertise already present in the LoP. Furthermore, junior doctors need a safe environment to embrace and reflect on the emotions aroused by interprofessional interactions, under the guidance of experienced facilitators.
从医学生到初级医生的转变具有挑战性。初级医生需要成为实践医生社区(CoP)的一部分,同时应对新的责任、任务和期望。与此同时,他们需要学习如何在与构成实践景观(LoP)的其他实践社区的边界和交叉点上进行导航。本研究旨在了解初级医生如何体验跨专业协作(IPC),以及考虑到他们向临床实践的过渡,是什么因素塑造了这些体验。
在这项多中心定性研究中,13 名初级医生分别绘制了两幅关于 IPC 体验的丰富图片,一幅是积极的,一幅是消极的。丰富的图片是一种视觉表现,是对特定情况的描绘,旨在捕捉体验的复杂和非语言元素。我们使用半结构化访谈来深入了解初级医生所描绘的 IPC 体验。我们迭代地分析了视觉材料和访谈记录,采用了归纳式建构主义主题分析。
在过渡到医生的过程中,初级医生首先成为医生 CoP 的成员,并根据他们在医生社区中感知到的价值观塑造自己的职业身份。跨专业学习是隐性发生的,没有来自跨专业团队的投入。结果,初级医生难以弥合自己和跨专业团队之间的差距,阻碍了 IPC 学习从发展成为一个整合的过程。这种职业孤立使初级医生在不了解其他人的角色、态度和期望的情况下在实践景观中徘徊。
IPC 学习需要成为一种集体努力和明确的学习目标,基于多源反馈,以充分利用 LoP 中已经存在的专业知识。此外,初级医生需要一个安全的环境,在有经验的促进者的指导下,接受和反思跨专业互动所引起的情绪。