Foulonneau V, Chantalat E, Prudhomme T, Gas J, Weyl A, Manuguerra A, Akakpo W, Baron M, Nedelec M, Dominique I, Gondran-Tellier B, Pradere B, Roumiguié M
Departement d'urologie, transplantation rénale et andrologie, CHU Toulouse, 1, avenue du Professeur Jean-Poulhès, 31400 Toulouse, France.
Anatomiste, service de gynécologie, CHU Toulouse, Toulouse, France.
Prog Urol. 2022 Mar;32(3):240-246. doi: 10.1016/j.purol.2021.10.006. Epub 2021 Dec 17.
The purpose of this study was to assess trainee urologists' [interns and assistant heads of university hospitals (CHU)] knowledge of the anatomy of the urogenital system. An examination consisting of 10 timed (16minutes) multiple-choice questions (MCQ) based on urogenital anatomy assessments for students in third year of the general medical science diploma program (DFGSM3) was sent to members of the French Association of Trainee Urologists (AFUF) in May 2018 in order to compare the average scores of these two populations. In addition, a questionnaire consisting of epidemiological data, their opinion on the quality of education in anatomy and the willingness to have more courses on this subject was included in the examination. The same scale based on a score out of 20 was applied to both populations. Of the 501 AFUF members solicited, 144 answered all the questions (28.7%). The mean score for urologists was lower than that of DFGSM3 students (10.56±1.82 vs. 11.4±2.37 respectively) (P=0.0013). Moreover, the desire for further education in anatomy was widespread among urologists (87%). According to our study, urologists have less knowledge of urogenital anatomy than third year medical students. Many means are being implemented or are available to rectify this failing, especially since the majority of trainee urologists consider that there are insufficient anatomy lessons in the curriculum and would like to receive further education in anatomy. LEVEL IF EVIDENCE: 3.
本研究的目的是评估泌尿外科实习医生(实习生和大学医院助理主任)对泌尿生殖系统解剖学的了解。2018年5月,一份由10道基于普通医学科学文凭课程三年级(DFGSM3)学生泌尿生殖解剖学评估的限时(16分钟)多项选择题(MCQ)组成的考试问卷被发送给法国泌尿外科实习医生协会(AFUF)的成员,以比较这两个人群的平均分数。此外,考试问卷还包括一份由流行病学数据、他们对解剖学教育质量的看法以及对该主题更多课程的意愿组成的问卷。两个群体都采用了基于20分制的相同评分标准。在501名被邀请的AFUF成员中,144人回答了所有问题(28.7%)。泌尿外科医生的平均分数低于DFGSM3学生(分别为10.56±1.82和11.4±2.37)(P=0.0013)。此外,泌尿外科医生中对解剖学继续教育的需求很普遍(87%)。根据我们的研究,泌尿外科医生对泌尿生殖解剖学的了解不如三年级医学生。目前正在实施或可以采用多种方法来纠正这一不足,特别是因为大多数泌尿外科实习医生认为课程中的解剖学课程不足,希望接受解剖学方面的继续教育。证据水平:3级。