Department of Bioethics, Lithuanian University of Health Sciences, Tilžės Str. 18, LT-47181 Kaunas, Lithuania.
Department of Health Management, Lithuanian University of Health Sciences, Tilžės Str. 18, LT-47181 Kaunas, Lithuania.
Medicina (Kaunas). 2021 Dec 1;57(12):1318. doi: 10.3390/medicina57121318.
The literature on professionals' perceptions of dignity at the end-of-life (EOL) shows that there is a need for studies set in different cultural contexts. Lithuania represents one of these little-studied contexts. The aim of this study is to understand professionals' attitudes, experiences, and suggestions concerning EOL dignity to provide knowledge upon which efforts to improve EOL care can be grounded. The research questions are "How do Lithuanian health care professionals understand the essence of dignity at the end-of-life of terminally ill patients?" and "How do they believe that dignity at the EOL can be enhanced?". The study was exploratory and descriptive. It employed an interpretive phenomenological method to understand the essence of the phenomenon. Lightly structured interviews were conducted with professionals who had EOL experience, primarily with elderly and late middle-aged patients. from medicine, nursing, social work, and spiritual services. The interviews were primarily conducted by audiovisual means due to pandemic restrictions. Using a constant comparative method, the research team systematically codified text and developed themes by consensus after numerous analytic data iterations. Four primary themes about EOL dignity were identified: Physical Comfort, Place of Care and Death, Effects of Death as a Taboo Topic, and Social Relations and Communication. A fifth, overarching theme, Being Heard, included elements of the primary themes and was identified as a key component or essence of dignity at the EOL. Patient dignity is both a human right and a constitutional right in Lithuania, but in many settings, it remains an aspiration rather than a reality. Being Heard is embedded in internationally recognized patient-centered models of EOL care. Hearing and acknowledging individuals who are dying is a specific skill, especially with elderly patients. Building the question "Is this patient being heard?" into practice protocols and conventions would be a step toward enhancing dignity at the EOL.
专业人员对临终尊严的看法文献表明,需要在不同文化背景下进行研究。立陶宛就是这种研究较少的背景之一。本研究旨在了解专业人员对临终尊严的态度、经验和建议,为努力改善临终关怀提供知识。研究问题是“立陶宛卫生保健专业人员如何理解终末期患者临终尊严的本质?”和“他们认为如何才能提高临终尊严?”。 该研究是探索性和描述性的。它采用解释现象学方法来理解现象的本质。对有临终经验的专业人员进行了轻度结构访谈,主要是对老年和中老年患者进行了访谈。来自医学、护理、社会工作和精神服务。由于大流行限制,访谈主要通过视听手段进行。研究小组使用恒定性比较方法,在多次分析数据迭代后,通过共识系统地对文本进行编码和开发主题。 确定了四个关于临终尊严的主要主题:身体舒适、护理和死亡地点、死亡作为禁忌话题的影响以及社会关系和沟通。第五个,总体主题,被听到,包括主要主题的要素,并被确定为临终尊严的关键组成部分或本质。 在立陶宛,患者尊严既是一项人权,也是一项宪法权利,但在许多情况下,它仍然是一种愿望,而不是现实。被听到是嵌入国际公认的以患者为中心的临终关怀模式的。倾听和承认临终的人是一种特殊的技能,尤其是对老年患者。将“患者是否被听到?”这个问题纳入实践协议和惯例将是提高临终尊严的一步。