Kyomuhangi Irene, Giorgi Emanuele
CHICAS, Lancaster University, Sir John Fisher Drive, Lancaster, UK.
Malar J. 2022 Jan 3;21(1):1. doi: 10.1186/s12936-021-04022-4.
In malaria serology analysis, the standard approach to obtain seroprevalence, i.e the proportion of seropositive individuals in a population, is based on a threshold which is used to classify individuals as seropositive or seronegative. The choice of this threshold is often arbitrary and is based on methods that ignore the age-dependency of the antibody distribution.
Using cross-sectional antibody data from the Western Kenyan Highlands, this paper introduces a novel approach that has three main advantages over the current threshold-based approach: it avoids the use of thresholds; it accounts for the age dependency of malaria antibodies; and it allows us to propagate the uncertainty from the classification of individuals into seropositive and seronegative when estimating seroprevalence. The reversible catalytic model is used as an example for illustrating how to propagate this uncertainty into the parameter estimates of the model.
This paper finds that accounting for age-dependency leads to a better fit to the data than the standard approach which uses a single threshold across all ages. Additionally, the paper also finds that the proposed threshold-free approach is more robust against the selection of different age-groups when estimating seroprevalence.
The novel threshold-free approach presented in this paper provides a statistically principled and more objective approach to estimating malaria seroprevalence. The introduced statistical framework also provides a means to compare results across studies which may use different age ranges for the estimation of seroprevalence.
在疟疾血清学分析中,获取血清阳性率(即人群中血清阳性个体的比例)的标准方法是基于一个阈值,该阈值用于将个体分类为血清阳性或血清阴性。这个阈值的选择通常是任意的,且基于忽略抗体分布年龄依赖性的方法。
利用来自肯尼亚西部高地的横断面抗体数据,本文介绍了一种新方法,该方法相对于当前基于阈值的方法具有三个主要优点:它避免了使用阈值;它考虑了疟疾抗体的年龄依赖性;并且在估计血清阳性率时,它允许我们将个体分类为血清阳性和血清阴性时的不确定性进行传播。以可逆催化模型为例,说明如何将这种不确定性传播到模型的参数估计中。
本文发现,与在所有年龄使用单一阈值的标准方法相比,考虑年龄依赖性能更好地拟合数据。此外,本文还发现,所提出的无阈值方法在估计血清阳性率时,对不同年龄组的选择更具稳健性。
本文提出的新型无阈值方法为估计疟疾血清阳性率提供了一种统计学上有原则且更客观的方法。引入的统计框架还提供了一种手段,用于比较不同研究的结果,这些研究可能使用不同的年龄范围来估计血清阳性率。