Kelly J V, Hellinger F J
Division of Intramural Research, National Center for Health Services Research, Rockville, MD 20857.
Health Serv Res. 1987 Aug;22(3):369-95.
This study examines the effects of selected characteristics of hospitals and physicians on the mortality rates of heart patients who survive their first day in the hospital. Separate multivariate regression analyses are conducted for three groups: (1) patients who undergo a direct heart revascularization or coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) operation; (2) patients who undergo a cardiac catheterization and do not undergo a CABG operation; and (3) patients with a principal diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction (AMI) who do not undergo surgery. The number of patients in each group treated by specific physicians, and the number treated in specific hospitals, measure provider experience with similar patients. Other hypothesized determinants of in-hospital mortality include: (1) patient severity of illness, age, sex, and the presence of comorbidities; (2) hospital ownership, size, location, teaching status, resources expended, and the presence of a coronary care unit; and (3) board certification status of the attending physician or surgeon who operated. Empirical results show that presence of a coronary care unit decreases the chance that CABG patients will die in the hospital but is not significant for other heart patients included in this study. Patients with atherosclerosis who receive a CABG or a cardiac catheterization procedure are more likely to survive in hospitals with high volumes of these procedures. However, hospital volume of AMI admissions was not a factor in survival; AMI patients are more likely to survive when their attending physicians treat high volumes of AMI patients. Also, AMI patients whose physicians are board certified in family practice or in internal medicine are less likely to die compared to AMI patients with physicians not board certified. Similarly, AMI patients hospitalized in teaching facilities are less likely to die compared to AMI patients in hospitals not affiliated with a medical school.
本研究考察了医院和医生的特定特征对在医院度过第一天后存活的心脏病患者死亡率的影响。针对三组患者分别进行了多元回归分析:(1)接受直接心脏血运重建或冠状动脉搭桥术(CABG)的患者;(2)接受心导管插入术但未接受CABG手术的患者;(3)主要诊断为急性心肌梗死(AMI)且未接受手术的患者。由特定医生治疗的每组患者数量以及在特定医院接受治疗的患者数量,衡量了医疗服务提供者对类似患者的治疗经验。其他假设的院内死亡率决定因素包括:(1)患者的疾病严重程度、年龄、性别以及合并症的存在情况;(2)医院的所有权、规模、位置、教学地位、资源消耗以及冠心病监护病房的存在情况;(3)主刀主治医生或外科医生的委员会认证状态。实证结果表明,冠心病监护病房的存在降低了CABG患者在医院死亡的几率,但对本研究纳入的其他心脏病患者而言并不显著。接受CABG或心导管插入术的动脉粥样硬化患者在进行这些手术量大的医院更有可能存活。然而,医院的AMI入院量并非存活的影响因素;当AMI患者的主治医生治疗大量AMI患者时,他们更有可能存活。此外,与医生未获得委员会认证的AMI患者相比,医生获得家庭医学或内科委员会认证的AMI患者死亡可能性更低。同样,与未附属于医学院的医院中的AMI患者相比,在教学机构住院的AMI患者死亡可能性更低。