Hannan E L, Kilburn H, O'Donnell J F, Bernard H R, Shields E P, Lindsey M L, Yazici A
New York State Department of Health, Office of Systems Management, Albany.
Health Serv Res. 1992 Oct;27(4):517-42.
This study uses New York State hospital discharge data to examine the relationship between in-hospital mortality for a patient receiving an abdominal aortic aneurysm resection and the volume of aneurysm operations performed in the previous year at the hospital where the operation took place and by the surgeon performing the operation. Previous research on this topic is extended in several respects: (1) A three-year data base is used to examine the manner in which hospital and surgeon volume jointly affect mortality rate and to examine ruptured and unruptured aneurysms separately; (2) a six-year data base is used to study the "practice makes perfect" hypothesis and the "selective referral" hypothesis; and (3) the degree of specialization of high-volume surgeons is contrasted with that of other surgeons. The results demonstrate a significant inverse relationship between hospital volume and mortality rate for unruptured aneurysms. Further, very few surgeons substantially increased their aneurysm surgery volumes in the six-year study period. Weak selective referral effects were found for both surgeons and hospitals, and higher-volume aneurysm surgeons tended to have much higher specialization rates.
本研究利用纽约州医院出院数据,来检验接受腹主动脉瘤切除术患者的院内死亡率,与前一年在手术实施医院以及实施手术的外科医生所进行的动脉瘤手术量之间的关系。此前关于该主题的研究在几个方面得到了拓展:(1)使用一个三年期数据库来检验医院和外科医生手术量共同影响死亡率的方式,并分别检验破裂和未破裂的动脉瘤;(2)使用一个六年期数据库来研究“熟能生巧”假说和“选择性转诊”假说;(3)将高手术量外科医生的专业化程度与其他外科医生的专业化程度进行对比。结果表明,对于未破裂动脉瘤,医院手术量与死亡率之间存在显著的负相关关系。此外,在六年的研究期内,很少有外科医生大幅增加其动脉瘤手术量。对于外科医生和医院,均发现了微弱的选择性转诊效应,并且手术量较高的动脉瘤外科医生往往具有高得多的专业化率。