Dezem Thaís Uenoyama, Franco Ademir, Machado Palhares Carlos Eduardo, Deitos Alexandre Raphael, Alves da Silva Ricardo Henrique, Santiago Bianca Marques, Arrais Ribeiro Isabella Lima, Junior Eduardo Daruge
Department of Social Odontology, Forensic Odontology Division, Piracicaba Dental School, State University of Campinas, Piracicaba, Brazil.
Division of Forensic Dentistry, Faculdade São Leopoldo Mandic, Instituto de Pesquisas São Leopoldo Mandic, Campinas, Brazil.
Acta Stomatol Croat. 2021 Dec;55(4):390-396. doi: 10.15644/asc55/4/6.
This study aimed to test the applicability of the methods proposed by Olze et al. (2012) and Timme et al. for dental age estimation in Brazilian subadults and adults.
Panoramic radiographs of 503 individuals aged between 20 and 70 years were analyzed. The mean chronological age of males and females of the sample was 29.04 and 29.97 years, receptively. Secondary dentin formation, cementum apposition, periodontal recession, and attrition of teeth #34, #35, #44 and #45 teeth were assessed as parameters to be calculated in the formulae designed by Olze et al. and Timme et al.
In males, the mean estimated age by the Olze method was 28.97 ± 2.86 years, while in females it was 27.85 ± 2.70 years. The Timme method estimated mean age for males of 32.54 ± 5.32 years and for females 33.09 ± 5.16 years. Low coefficients of determination (r) for the application of tooth-specific formulae of both methods suggest that estimated and chronological ages were not properly associated.
The outcomes of this study indicate that the Olze and Timme methods may be limited for forensic applications in Brazilian subadults and adults. Country-specific statistical adjustments might be useful for improvements in practice.
本研究旨在测试Olze等人(2012年)以及Timme等人提出的方法在巴西青少年和成年人牙齿年龄估计中的适用性。
分析了503名年龄在20至70岁之间个体的全景X线片。样本中男性和女性的平均实际年龄分别为29.04岁和29.97岁。评估了34、35、44和45号牙的继发性牙本质形成、牙骨质附着、牙周退缩和磨损情况,作为Olze等人和Timme等人设计公式中要计算的参数。
在男性中,Olze方法估计的平均年龄为28.97±2.86岁,而在女性中为27.85±2.70岁。Timme方法估计男性的平均年龄为32.54±5.32岁,女性为33.09±5.16岁。两种方法应用牙齿特异性公式时的低决定系数(r)表明估计年龄和实际年龄没有很好地关联。
本研究结果表明,Olze和Timme方法在巴西青少年和成年人的法医应用中可能存在局限性。针对特定国家的统计调整可能有助于在实践中改进。