Tsvetkov Nadejda, Zayed Amro
Department of Biology York University Toronto ON Canada.
Ecol Evol. 2021 Dec 20;11(24):18733-18742. doi: 10.1002/ece3.8480. eCollection 2021 Dec.
Neonicotinoid insecticides have been implicated in honey bee declines, with many studies showing that sublethal exposure impacts bee behaviors such as foraging, learning, and memory. Despite the large number of ecotoxicological studies carried out to date, most focus on a handful of worker phenotypes leading to a "streetlight effect" where the choice of phenotypes to measure may influence the results and conclusions arising from the studies. This bias can be overcome with the use of toxicological transcriptomics, where changes in gene expression can provide a more objective view of how pesticides alter animal traits. Here, we used RNA sequencing to examine the changes in neurogenomic states of nurse and forager honey bees that were naturally exposed to neonicotinoids in the field and artificially exposed to neonicotinoids in a controlled experiment. We found that neonicotinoid exposure influenced the neurogenomic state of foragers and nurses in different ways; foragers experienced shifts in expression of genes involved in cognition and development, while nurses experienced shifts in expression of genes involved in metabolism. Our study suggests that neonicotinoids influence nurse and forager bees in a different manner. We also found no to minimal overlap in the differentially expressed genes in our study and in previously published studies, which might help reconcile the seemingly contradictory results often reported in the neonicotinoid literature.
新烟碱类杀虫剂被认为与蜜蜂数量减少有关,许多研究表明,亚致死剂量的接触会影响蜜蜂的行为,如觅食、学习和记忆。尽管迄今为止已经进行了大量的生态毒理学研究,但大多数研究集中在少数几种工蜂表型上,导致了一种“路灯效应”,即所选择测量的表型可能会影响研究结果和结论。使用毒理转录组学可以克服这种偏差,基因表达的变化可以提供一个更客观的视角,了解农药如何改变动物特征。在这里,我们使用RNA测序来研究在野外自然接触新烟碱类杀虫剂以及在对照实验中人工接触新烟碱类杀虫剂的保育蜂和觅食蜂的神经基因组状态变化。我们发现,接触新烟碱类杀虫剂以不同方式影响觅食蜂和保育蜂的神经基因组状态;觅食蜂在参与认知和发育的基因表达上发生变化,而保育蜂在参与代谢的基因表达上发生变化。我们的研究表明,新烟碱类杀虫剂以不同方式影响保育蜂和觅食蜂。我们还发现,在我们的研究和先前发表的研究中,差异表达基因几乎没有重叠,这可能有助于调和新烟碱类文献中经常报道的看似矛盾的结果。