Öhman-Mägi Caroline, Holub Ondrej, Wu Dan, Hall Richard M, Persson Cecilia
Department of Materials Science and Engineering Uppsala University Uppsala Sweden.
School of Mechanical Engineering University of Leeds Leeds UK.
JOR Spine. 2021 Nov 9;4(4):e1176. doi: 10.1002/jsp2.1176. eCollection 2021 Dec.
Being able to predict the mechanical properties of vertebrae in patients with osteoporosis and other relevant pathologies is essential to prevent fractures and to develop the most favorable fracture treatments. Furthermore, a reliable prediction is important for developing more patient- and pathology-specific biomaterials. A plethora of studies correlating bone density to mechanical properties has been reported; however, the results are variable, due to a variety of factors, including anatomical site and methodological differences. The aim of this study was to provide a comprehensive literature review on density and mechanical properties of human vertebral trabecular bone as well as relationships found between these properties. A literature search was performed to include studies, which investigated mechanical properties and bone density of trabecular bone. Only studies on vertebral trabecular bone tissue, reporting bone density or mechanical properties, were kept. A large variation in reported vertebral trabecular bone densities, mechanical properties, and relationships between the two was found, as exemplified by values varying between 0.09 and 0.35 g/cm for the wet apparent density and from 0.1 to 976 MPa for the elastic modulus. The differences were found to reflect variations in experimental and analytical processes that had been used, including testing protocol and specimen geometry. The variability in the data decreased in studies where bone tissue testing occurred in a standardized manner (eg, the reported differences in average elastic modulus decreased from 400% to 10%). It is important to take this variability into account when analyzing the predictions found in the literature, for example, to calculate fracture risk, and it is recommended to use the models suggested in the present review to reduce data variability.
能够预测骨质疏松症及其他相关病症患者椎骨的力学性能,对于预防骨折以及制定最适宜的骨折治疗方案至关重要。此外,可靠的预测对于开发更具患者和病症特异性的生物材料也很重要。已有大量关于骨密度与力学性能相关性的研究报道;然而,由于包括解剖部位和方法差异等多种因素,结果各不相同。本研究的目的是对人体椎体小梁骨的密度和力学性能以及这些性能之间的关系进行全面的文献综述。进行了文献检索,纳入了研究小梁骨力学性能和骨密度的研究。仅保留了关于椎体小梁骨组织、报告骨密度或力学性能的研究。发现报告的椎体小梁骨密度、力学性能以及两者之间的关系存在很大差异,例如,湿表观密度的值在0.09至0.35 g/cm之间变化,弹性模量在0.1至976 MPa之间变化。发现这些差异反映了所使用的实验和分析过程中的变化,包括测试方案和标本几何形状。在以标准化方式进行骨组织测试的研究中,数据的变异性降低(例如,报告的平均弹性模量差异从400%降至10%)。在分析文献中的预测结果(例如计算骨折风险)时,考虑这种变异性很重要,建议使用本综述中提出的模型来降低数据变异性。