Lane Kaycie, Fuller Megan, Dyment Travis, Gagnon Graham
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, MA, USA.
Center for Water and Resource Studies, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2022 Mar;240:113916. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2021.113916. Epub 2022 Jan 7.
Despite several years of targeted interventions, First Nations drinking water systems in Canada remain under-resourced and require substantial improvements in both infrastructure and management to provide communities with safe drinking water. The purpose of this study was to co-develop a risk assessment process integral to the water safety planning methodology to determine if proactive risk assessment provides a beneficial management tool for First Nations water systems. We co-developed a risk assessment web-application with First Nations stakeholders to identify hazards and assess risk in six Atlantic region First Nations communities. Using this application, we were able to successfully identify high-risk hazards in each community, both risks specific to individual systems, and risks common at a regional level. Through semi-structured interviews we identified the following benefits of a risk assessment web application: increased communication, data ownership and centralized data management. However, challenges remain, including current fragmented governance realities, and liability concerns associated with adopting a new risk management strategy. Successful adoption of proactive risk management strategies in First Nations communities will depend on strong co-development of risk assessment tools, transparent communication between stakeholders and clearly defined data ownership and management practices.
尽管经过数年的针对性干预,但加拿大原住民饮用水系统资源仍然不足,需要在基础设施和管理方面进行大幅改进,才能为社区提供安全饮用水。本研究的目的是共同开发一个融入水安全规划方法的风险评估流程,以确定前瞻性风险评估是否为原住民供水系统提供有益的管理工具。我们与原住民利益相关者共同开发了一个风险评估网络应用程序,以识别六个大西洋地区原住民社区的危害并评估风险。使用该应用程序,我们成功识别了每个社区的高风险危害,包括特定于各个系统的风险以及区域层面常见的风险。通过半结构化访谈,我们确定了风险评估网络应用程序的以下好处:加强沟通、数据所有权和集中数据管理。然而,挑战依然存在,包括当前治理碎片化的现实,以及采用新风险管理策略带来的责任问题。在原住民社区成功采用前瞻性风险管理策略将取决于风险评估工具的有力共同开发、利益相关者之间的透明沟通以及明确界定的数据所有权和管理实践。