Rickert Daniela, Simon Ralph, von Fersen Lorenzo, Baumgartner Katrin, Bertsch Thomas, Kirschbaum Clemens, Erhard Michael
Nuremberg Zoo, 90480 Nuremberg, Germany.
Department of Veterinary Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Institute of Animal Welfare, Ethology and Animal Hygiene, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, 80637 Munich, Germany.
Animals (Basel). 2021 Dec 23;12(1):22. doi: 10.3390/ani12010022.
A central task of zoos and aquaria is the frequent and accurate assessment of their animals' welfare. Recently, important steps have been made, such as the introduction of animal welfare evaluation tools and welfare decision trees. To determine animal welfare, it is not only important to collect life history data, such as longevity and reproductive success, but also for experienced observers or caretakers to conduct behavioral observations on a regular basis to assess animals' emotional state. To physiologically validate welfare observations, glucocorticoid levels are usually assessed, as they are a common indicator of stress. While, for many animals, these levels can be easily determined via fecal or hair samples, for cetaceans, the levels are usually determined via blood samples. As blood samples cannot be taken very frequently and the process may cause stress to the animals (if the samples are not taken following medical training), other techniques, such as the measurement of health biomarkers (especially cortisol, which can be measured in saliva), have become the focus of cetacean stress research. However, there are two problems associated with saliva measurements in cetaceans: saliva might either be diluted with pool water or be contaminated by fodder fish, as frozen fish usually contains high levels of cortisol. In our study, we investigated how saliva cortisol levels are connected to blood cortisol levels and how saliva cortisol can be influenced by fodder fish. We examined saliva and blood samples in eleven bottlenose dolphins () kept in an outdoor and indoor facility in Germany. Furthermore, we assessed the cortisol levels of different kinds of fodder fish. Our data show that, although saliva cortisol values are elevated under stress and arousal, they seem not to be correlated with blood cortisol values. We also show that, after feeding, saliva cortisol values are increased up to 100-fold. Our results suggest that saliva cortisol measurements in dolphins have to be conducted and considered with care, as they can easily be contaminated. Moreover, it is important to use the right laboratory method in order to specifically detect cortisol; in our study, we conducted reliable tests, using LC-MS/MS.
动物园和水族馆的一项核心任务是对其动物的福利进行频繁且准确的评估。最近,已经取得了重要进展,例如引入了动物福利评估工具和福利决策树。为了确定动物福利,不仅收集诸如寿命和繁殖成功率等生活史数据很重要,对于经验丰富的观察者或饲养员来说,定期进行行为观察以评估动物的情绪状态也很重要。为了从生理上验证福利观察结果,通常会评估糖皮质激素水平,因为它们是压力的常见指标。虽然对于许多动物来说,这些水平可以通过粪便或毛发样本轻松确定,但对于鲸类动物,这些水平通常通过血液样本确定。由于不能非常频繁地采集血液样本,而且这个过程可能会给动物带来压力(如果样本采集没有遵循医学培训),其他技术,如健康生物标志物的测量(特别是可以在唾液中测量的皮质醇),已成为鲸类动物压力研究的重点。然而,在鲸类动物中进行唾液测量存在两个问题:唾液可能会被池水污染,或者被饲料鱼污染,因为冷冻鱼通常含有高水平的皮质醇。在我们的研究中,我们调查了唾液皮质醇水平与血液皮质醇水平之间的关系,以及饲料鱼如何影响唾液皮质醇。我们检查了德国一个室内外设施中饲养的11只宽吻海豚()的唾液和血液样本。此外,我们评估了不同种类饲料鱼的皮质醇水平。我们的数据表明,虽然唾液皮质醇值在压力和兴奋状态下会升高,但它们似乎与血液皮质醇值没有相关性。我们还表明,喂食后,唾液皮质醇值会增加高达100倍。我们的结果表明,在海豚中进行唾液皮质醇测量时必须谨慎进行并加以考虑,因为它们很容易被污染。此外,使用正确的实验室方法以专门检测皮质醇很重要;在我们的研究中,我们使用液相色谱 - 串联质谱法(LC - MS/MS)进行了可靠的测试。