Arrow Peter, Forrest Helen, Piggott Susan
WA Dental Health Services, Perth, WA, Australia.
Australian Research Centre for Population Oral Health, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Front Oral Health. 2021 Apr 23;2:656530. doi: 10.3389/froh.2021.656530. eCollection 2021.
Parents of children treated under dental general anaesthesia (DGA) have reported feelings of concern and anxiety. This study elicited the views of parents/carers (P/C) of children with early childhood caries (ECC) who participated in a randomised trial (core study) which tested the effectiveness of care under DGA or care using alternative minimally invasive Atraumatic Restorative Treatment and the Hall Technique approaches (ART/HT). P/C of children treated using the ART/HT (test) approach or care under a DGA (control) were interviewed. Focus group semi-structured interviews with P/C were undertaken in community facilities. The transcripts were read and inductively coded into domains to identify emergent themes. The codes were entered into NVivo software to assist data management and were further refined into broad themes. Seven grouped interviews with 14 participants were conducted and one test participant provided a written response. Four groups with eight test participants; two groups with four control participants; and one combined group with one test and one control participant were interviewed. Five broad themes emerged after thematic analysis: (1) Impacts on the child and the family; (2) Child-/family-centred care; (3) Timeliness of care; (4) Affordable care; (5) Accessible care. Impacts were related to that of the effects of the disease, and of the care for the disease. Child-centred/family-centred care (CCC) was a source of appreciation by P/C of both groups when it was experienced. Frustration at the lack of timely care of their child's treatment needs, coupled with the perceived expensiveness of care and difficulties in physically getting to the location for a specialist consultation was expressed by P/Cs in the study. The use of the ART/HT enabled the establishment of a relationship between the clinical team and the child and P/C which was central to the delivery of CCC. P/Cs in the DGA arm of the study expressed dissatisfaction more often with the issues of timely care, cost of care and accessibility of care. P/C of both groups were equally satisfied with the treatment, where treatment had been received in a timely, child-centred manner. The findings suggest that minimally invasive approaches which facilitated CCC are acceptable alternative options to the DGA and should be considered for the management of ECC. ACTRN12616001124426.
接受牙科全身麻醉(DGA)治疗的儿童的家长表示有担忧和焦虑情绪。本研究征集了患有幼儿龋齿(ECC)的儿童的家长/照顾者(P/C)的意见,这些家长/照顾者参与了一项随机试验(核心研究),该试验测试了DGA下的治疗效果或使用替代性微创非创伤性修复治疗及霍尔技术方法(ART/HT)的治疗效果。对采用ART/HT(试验)方法或DGA下的治疗(对照)的儿童的P/C进行了访谈。在社区设施中对P/C进行了焦点小组半结构化访谈。对访谈记录进行阅读,并归纳编码到各个领域以识别新出现的主题。将代码输入NVivo软件以协助数据管理,并进一步提炼为广泛的主题。对14名参与者进行了7组访谈,1名试验参与者提供了书面回复。对4组共8名试验参与者、2组共4名对照参与者以及1组由1名试验参与者和1名对照参与者组成的混合组进行了访谈。主题分析后出现了5个广泛的主题:(1)对儿童和家庭的影响;(2)以儿童/家庭为中心的护理;(3)护理的及时性;(4)可承受的护理;(5)可获得的护理。影响与疾病的影响以及疾病的护理有关。当体验到以儿童为中心/以家庭为中心的护理(CCC)时,两组的P/C都对此表示赞赏。研究中的P/C表达了对孩子治疗需求缺乏及时护理的沮丧,以及对护理费用高昂和前往专科咨询地点的实际困难的感受。ART/HT的使用使得临床团队与儿童及P/C之间建立了一种关系,这是提供CCC的核心。研究中DGA组的P/C对护理的及时性、护理费用和可获得性问题的不满更为常见。两组的P/C对以及时、以儿童为中心的方式接受的治疗同样满意。研究结果表明,促进CCC的微创方法是DGA的可接受替代选择,在ECC的管理中应予以考虑。ACTRN12616001124426。