Meulenbroeks Ralph, van Joolingen Wouter R
Freudenthal Institute, Utrecht University, the Netherlands.
Heliyon. 2022 Jan 11;8(1):e08733. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e08733. eCollection 2022 Jan.
As education was forced to go fully online in early 2020 as a consequence of the imposed lockdowns, concerns were raised related to student well-being. This study examines student well-being at the science faculty of a large urban university in the Netherlands within the framework of Basic Psychological Need Theory, a sub-theory of Self-Determination Theory. A mixed-methods approach was adopted, combining the results of an online student survey with 16 Likert-scale questions as well as two open ended questions (2228 participants, corresponding to a response rate of 32%) with a student focus group interview. The Likert-scale questions were subjected to factor analyses and reveal problems with well-being in four areas: study, personal worries, personal well-being, and societal worries. The analyses of the answers to the open ended questions as well as the focus group data show that students are positive on the autonomy offered by the inherent flexibility of online education, e.g., as a consequence of reduced travel time. However, the psychological needs of competence and relatedness are seriously undermined during times of lockdown, mainly because of poorer student-teacher interaction, lack of structure, loneliness, and helplessness. Students state that they need more support in these areas, for example by on-campus meetings whenever possible, psychological support, improvements in online education, online social events, adequate communication, and leniency in the interpretation of regulations and deadlines. Implications are discussed.
由于2020年初实施封锁,教育被迫全面转向线上,人们对学生的幸福感产生了担忧。本研究在自决理论的子理论——基本心理需求理论的框架内,考察了荷兰一所大型城市大学理学院学生的幸福感。采用了混合方法,将一项包含16个李克特量表问题以及两个开放式问题的在线学生调查结果(2228名参与者,对应32%的回复率)与一个学生焦点小组访谈相结合。对李克特量表问题进行了因子分析,揭示了四个方面的幸福感问题:学习、个人担忧、个人幸福感和社会担忧。对开放式问题答案以及焦点小组数据的分析表明,学生对在线教育内在灵活性所提供的自主性持积极态度,例如,由于出行时间减少。然而,在封锁期间,能力和归属感的心理需求受到严重影响,主要原因是师生互动较差、缺乏条理、孤独和无助感。学生们表示,他们在这些方面需要更多支持,例如尽可能举行校内会议、心理支持、改善在线教育、举办在线社交活动、进行充分沟通以及在规章制度和截止日期的解释上更加宽松。文中讨论了相关影响。