Tikochinski Refael, Babad Elisha
Seymour Fox School of Education, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Mount Scopus, Jerusalem, Israel.
J Nonverbal Behav. 2022;46(2):215-229. doi: 10.1007/s10919-022-00397-3. Epub 2022 Jan 28.
The Media Bias Effect (MBE) represents the biasing influence of the nonverbal behavior of a TV interviewer on viewers' impressions of the interviewee. In the MBE experiment, participants view a 4-min made-up political interview in which they are exposed only to the nonverbal behavior of the actors. The interviewer is friendly toward the politician in one experimental condition and hostile in the other. The interviewee was a confederate filmed in the same studio, and his clips are identical in the two conditions. This experiment was used successfully in a series of studies in several countries (Babad and Peer in J Nonverbal Behav 34(1):57-78, 2010. 10.1007/s10919-009-0078-x) and was administered in the present research. The present investigation focused on the interviewer's source credibility and its persuasive influence. The viewers filled out questionnaires about their impressions of both the interviewer and the interviewee. A component of "interviewer's authority" was derived in PCA, with substantial variance in viewers' impressions of the interviewer. In our design, we preferred the conception of Epistemic Authority (Kruglanski et al. in Adv Exp Soc Psychol 37:345-392, 2005)-based on viewers' subjective perceptions for deriving authority status-to the conventional design of source credibility studies, where dimensions of authority are pre-determined as independent variables. The results demonstrated that viewers who perceived the interviewer as an effective leader demonstrated a clear MBE and were susceptible to his influencing bias, but no bias effect was found for viewers who did not perceive the interviewer as an effective leader. Thus, Epistemic Authority (source credibility) moderated the Media Bias Effect.
媒体偏见效应(MBE)指电视采访者的非语言行为对观众对被采访者印象的偏见性影响。在MBE实验中,参与者观看一段4分钟的虚构政治采访,在此过程中他们只接触到演员的非语言行为。在一种实验条件下,采访者对政治家态度友好,而在另一种条件下则充满敌意。被采访者是在同一演播室拍摄的一名同谋,他的片段在两种条件下完全相同。该实验在多个国家的一系列研究中得到成功运用(巴巴德和皮尔,《非语言行为杂志》,2010年,第34卷第1期,第57 - 78页。doi:10.1007/s10919 - 009 - 0078 - x),并应用于本研究。本调查聚焦于采访者的来源可信度及其说服性影响。观众填写了关于他们对采访者和被采访者印象的问卷。在主成分分析中得出了“采访者权威性”这一成分,观众对采访者的印象存在显著差异。在我们的设计中,相较于来源可信度研究的传统设计(其中权威性维度被预先确定为自变量),我们更倾向于基于观众主观认知来推导权威地位的认知权威概念(克鲁格兰斯基等人,《实验社会心理学进展》,2005年,第37卷,第345 - 392页)。结果表明,将采访者视为有效领导者的观众表现出明显的MBE,且容易受到其影响偏差的影响,但对于不将采访者视为有效领导者的观众则未发现偏差效应。因此,认知权威(来源可信度)调节了媒体偏见效应。