Department of Surgery, Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Cancer Center Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Nursing Sciences, Program in Clinical Health Sciences, University Medical Center Utrecht, University Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
BMC Surg. 2022 Feb 2;22(1):38. doi: 10.1186/s12893-021-01445-3.
Early structured mobilization has become a key element of Enhanced Recovery After Surgery programs to improve patient outcomes and decrease length of hospital stay. With the intention to assess and improve early mobilization levels, the 8-point ordinal John Hopkins Highest Level of Mobility (JH-HLM) scale was implemented at two gastrointestinal and oncological surgery wards in the Netherlands. After the implementation, however, healthcare professionals perceived a ceiling effect in assessing mobilization after gastrointestinal and oncological surgery. This study aimed to quantify this perceived ceiling effect, and aimed to determine if extending the JH-HLM scale with four additional response categories into the AMsterdam UMC EXtension of the JOhn HOpkins Highest Level of mObility (AMEXO) scale reduced this ceiling effect.
All patients who underwent gastrointestinal and oncological surgery and had a mobility score on the first postoperative day before (July-December 2018) or after (July-December 2019) extending the JH-HLM into the AMEXO scale were included. The primary outcome was the before-after difference in the percentage of ceiling effects on the first three postoperative days. Furthermore, the before-after changes and distributions in mobility scores were evaluated. Univariable and multivariable logistic regression analysis were used to assess these differences.
Overall, 373 patients were included (JH-HLM n = 135; AMEXO n = 238). On the first postoperative day, 61 (45.2%) patients scored the highest possible mobility score before extending the JH-HLM into the AMEXO as compared to 4 (1.7%) patients after (OR = 0.021, CI = 0.007-0.059, p < 0.001). During the first three postoperative days, 118 (87.4%) patients scored the highest possible mobility score before compared to 40 (16.8%) patients after (OR = 0.028, CI = 0.013-0.060, p < 0.001). A change in mobility was observed in 88 (65.2%) patients before as compared to 225 (94.5%) patients after (OR = 9.101, CI = 4.046-20.476, p < 0.001). Of these 225 patients, the four additional response categories were used in 165 (73.3%) patients.
A substantial ceiling effect was present in assessing early mobilization in patients after gastrointestinal and oncological surgery using the JH-HLM. Extending the JH-HLM into the AMEXO scale decreased the ceiling effect significantly, making the tool more appropriate to assess early mobilization and set daily mobilization goals after gastrointestinal and oncological surgery.
早期结构化的活动已成为增强术后康复计划的关键要素,以改善患者的预后并缩短住院时间。为了评估和提高早期活动水平,8 点约翰霍普金斯最高活动水平(JH-HLM)量表在荷兰的两个胃肠和肿瘤外科病房实施。然而,在实施后,医疗保健专业人员在评估胃肠和肿瘤手术后的活动水平时发现存在天花板效应。本研究旨在量化这种感知到的天花板效应,并确定是否通过将 JH-HLM 量表扩展为 4 个额外的反应类别来扩展到 AMsterdam UMC EXtension of the JOhn HOpkins Highest Level of mObility(AMEXO)量表可以减少这种天花板效应。
所有接受胃肠和肿瘤手术并在术后第 1 天(2018 年 7 月至 12 月前)或之后(2019 年 7 月至 12 月)使用 JH-HLM 进行移动性评分的患者均被纳入研究。主要结局是在前三天术后评估中天花板效应的百分比的前后差异。此外,还评估了移动性评分的前后变化和分布。使用单变量和多变量逻辑回归分析评估这些差异。
总体而言,纳入了 373 名患者(JH-HLM 组 n=135;AMEXO 组 n=238)。在术后第 1 天,与扩展 JH-HLM 进入 AMEXO 之前相比,有 61(45.2%)名患者获得了最高可能的活动水平评分,而仅有 4(1.7%)名患者获得了最高可能的活动水平评分(OR=0.021,95%CI=0.007-0.059,p<0.001)。在前三天术后期间,与扩展 JH-HLM 进入 AMEXO 之前相比,有 118(87.4%)名患者获得了最高可能的活动水平评分,而仅有 40(16.8%)名患者获得了最高可能的活动水平评分(OR=0.028,95%CI=0.013-0.060,p<0.001)。在扩展 JH-HLM 进入 AMEXO 之前,有 88(65.2%)名患者的活动水平发生了变化,而扩展 JH-HLM 进入 AMEXO 之后,有 225(94.5%)名患者的活动水平发生了变化(OR=9.101,95%CI=4.046-20.476,p<0.001)。在这 225 名患者中,有 165(73.3%)名患者使用了 4 个额外的反应类别。
在使用 JH-HLM 评估胃肠和肿瘤手术后患者的早期活动时,存在明显的天花板效应。将 JH-HLM 扩展到 AMEXO 量表显著降低了天花板效应,使该工具更适合评估胃肠和肿瘤手术后的早期活动,并设定每日活动目标。