De Clerck Ivo, Walgraeve Vincent, Snoeck Robert, Andrei Graciela, Blanckaert Johan, Mulliez Evelyne, Delbeke Heleen
University Hospitals Leuven, Department of Ophthalmology, Herestraat 49, 3000, Leuven, Belgium.
Rega Institute for Medical Research, Laboratory of Virology and Chemotherapy, Herestraat 49, 3000, Leuven, Belgium.
Am J Ophthalmol Case Rep. 2022 Jan 21;25:101268. doi: 10.1016/j.ajoc.2022.101268. eCollection 2022 Mar.
To strengthen the sparse evidence on acyclovir (ACV) resistance, especially in recalcitrant herpetic keratitis (HK), by describing the clinical course of 3 genotypically proven ACV resistant HK cases. An overview of mechanisms of resistance and therapeutic options currently available to ophthalmologists is provided based upon recent literature search.
Resistance to ACV due to known mutations in the gene encoding the viral thymidine kinase was confirmed in 2 cases, and a novel mutation in the UL23 gene (N202K) conferring phenotypical resistance to ACV was discovered in 1 case. Three unique therapeutic strategies finally led to epithelial closure.
The novel thymidine kinase mutation (N202K) should be considered to infer resistance to all molecules requiring activation by the viral thymidine kinase. Current topical alternatives in the ophthalmologist's armamentarium include trifluridine 1%, foscarnet 1,2%-1,4% or cidofovir 0,2-0,5%. Epithelial debridement, high-frequency dosing and reduction of immunosuppression are useful adjuncts.
Clinicians should perform epithelial debridement in recalcitrant HK, allowing geno- and phenotypically guided therapy, even without a history of long-term anti-viral prophylaxis or recurrent HK. This report provides mandatory knowledge allowing the reader to comprehend how therapy should be altered based upon these results. To the best of our knowledge, successful treatment of proven ACV resistant HK with topical foscarnet has not yet previously been published.Furthermore, this paper highlights a lack of controlled studies investigating alternative topical treatments in case of viral resistance, offering opportunities for future research.
通过描述3例经基因分型证实的阿昔洛韦(ACV)耐药性疱疹性角膜炎(HK)病例的临床病程,加强关于ACV耐药性的稀少证据,尤其是在顽固性HK中。基于近期文献检索,提供对耐药机制及眼科医生目前可用治疗选择的概述。
在2例病例中证实了由于编码病毒胸苷激酶的基因发生已知突变而导致对ACV耐药,在1例病例中发现了UL23基因中的一个新突变(N202K),该突变赋予对ACV的表型耐药性。三种独特的治疗策略最终导致上皮愈合。
应考虑新的胸苷激酶突变(N202K)以推断对所有需要病毒胸苷激酶激活的分子的耐药性。眼科医生现有治疗手段中的当前局部替代药物包括1%的三氟尿苷、1.2%-1.4%的膦甲酸钠或0.2-0.5%的西多福韦。上皮清创术、高频给药和减少免疫抑制是有用的辅助手段。
临床医生应在顽固性HK中进行上皮清创术,即使没有长期抗病毒预防或复发性HK病史,也可进行基因和表型指导的治疗。本报告提供了必要的知识,使读者能够理解应如何根据这些结果改变治疗方法。据我们所知,此前尚未发表过用局部膦甲酸钠成功治疗经证实的ACV耐药性HK的报道。此外,本文强调缺乏针对病毒耐药情况下替代局部治疗的对照研究,为未来研究提供了机会。